-
November 2023 by Kaufenanger
Kind friendly staff and fair prices, will come agian.
-
November 2023 by David M
Poor customer service, lady behind counter is extremely aggressive and rude. Raises prices when you ask to buy. Hard pass
-
September 2023 by B Maggis
When they do not value the coin nor jewelry and give you discounted off of spot run far away if you are selling vintage coins.
-
June 2023 by Howard Chen
Great experience. Staffs are always warm and welcoming. Highly recommended.
-
June 2023 by Melkor
Had a great experience here. Super fun team working here with lots of experience and fair pricing.
-
May 2023 by John Leibold
Got an engagement ring resized and refurbished. Fast, professional service. Great advice, an honest range of options. Jared is your go-to guy. Also, much more than jewelry here. Silver, antiques, ancient coins, etc. A cool place even if it's just to take a look around
-
April 2023 by CK S
I always have a wonderful experience at Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay. Each professional on staff is friendly and helpful. They are experts in their field, yet patient with my novice questions. If you have no idea where to start in buying gold and silver you need to visit and start here!
-
March 2023 by Blake Nelson
Went in to Coin Galleries to sell my gold and was very happy with the price! I had shopped around to two other local places in the area and they had given me the highest price. Jared advised me not to sell one of my grandmothers rings because it was so sentimental and he actually created a custom necklace with the diamonds! It is beautiful and I have been wearing it ever since. Highly recommend using Coin Galleries for selling gold and all your jewelry needs!
-
March 2023 by TheMainConnects
Wonderful experience every time I go there. Best prices and you always have peace of mind buying and selling with them. Very friendly and respectful staff. All the products are always available and everyone there is very knowledgeable. Amy was amazing. Best bullion dealer in NY, hands down.
-
March 2023 by Son-of- the-Republic
I’ve been coming here for many years. I’m an avid gold/silver trader and I don’t even bother going anywhere else anymore.Ira and his son Jarred can get any trade done you need. whether you need to sell jewelry, buy coins, or trade bullion, this is the place to go
-
March 2023 by Danielle Slayton
I have both bought and sold at the Coin Gallery over the last decade. They have always provided an outstanding value and have been more than fair on both ends. When purchasing custom jewelry, this is the only place I shop. We are so lucky to have such a gem in Oyster Bay!
-
March 2023 by Arthur Behal
I have been a customer for over a decade at all of their locations. The team has always been friendly and helpful, and I have referred friends.
-
March 2023 by joanne cohen
STAY FAR AWAY. THIEVES. LITERALLY.A STORY I DO NOT CARE TO SHARE BC ITS TOO UPSETTING. I SHOULD HV READ THE OTHER HORRIBLE REVIEWS. I DONT KNOW HOW THIS GUY SLEEPS AT NIGHT. DISHONEST. BAD KARMA. STAY AWAY!
-
March 2023 by Jamie Stamataky
I have only had great experiences at this store. Highly recommend this family run small business!!
-
March 2023 by Carolyn DiPasquale
Friendly, helpful service. Will definitely go back. Amy was great to work with.