Insurance near Oyster Bay, NY

30 locations found near Oyster Bay

“Bill and his team consistently provide excellent and efficient service. In the unfortunate instances we have had to utilize our insurances, Bill has personally walked myself and my husband through the necessary steps to be taken and continuously followed up until everything was resolved. I highly recommend working with Bill Hannan!”

4.8 Superb51 Reviews

“Mr. Elbogen....and all his staff are extremely highly trained professionals.
They have all been helping myself and my family members and a multitude of my friends, with their Supreme service. , ...they truly have astute working knowledge of all lines of insurance. They make us feel like truly valued customers, answer all of our concerns, offer top knotch advice, truly and amazing group of true humanitarians......I am 62 years old and have been with state farm since I was 18 years of age. I urge, and implore all people to please use this state farm agency. You will not be disappointed as their level of intelligence and insightfullness of ins is truly amazing.
Please I urge you to give them a call.
Especially with the new market place increases. Excellent group of what a true professional us. ? C
ordially, Laura Scundakis

UPDATED REVIEW WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER 03, 2025

Customer Service rep Miss Sanjida is wonderful and excellent and helped me with all my needs. She is one of the many outstanding reasons why I have stayed with State Farm for over the last 4 decades. Please give this delightful individual a five star rating. Thank you.
Laura Scundakis”

5 Superb178 Reviews

“I went to purchase a car on a SUNDAY, and everything went smoothly up until I needed auto insurance, so the sales rep helped me with getting quotes with the big companies and all of them came back reasonable but high…so that’s when the rep suggested calling his broker (Jesse) from the Michaels Group - and not only did he respond within minutes, he was able to quote me and start my policy within the hour! & furthermore, Jesse was able to do all this on a SUNDAY and while waiting to board an international flight! Needless to say, I highly highly recommend Jesse from The Michaels Group for all of your insurance needs Auto home anything 10 stars all the way thanks brother!!! - Chase”

5 Superb160 Reviews

“Matt Benincasa is the man! Helped me to not only increase my coverage significantly at the same price i had gotten elsewhere, but was able to bundle the policy for my new car. Thanks Matt!”

5 Superb151 Reviews

“Joe and team are quick to respond with any questions and concise as well, great group and easy to deal with, especially after dealing with a competitor who made things difficult. Glad I made the switch to Joe’s team.”

5 Superb121 Reviews

“Kiara is an amazing insurance agent! She is super personable and made the entire process stress-free. Her communication is excellent – she was always quick to respond and explained everything clearly. I really appreciated how she took the time to work with me and my budget while still making sure I had the right coverage.”

5 Superb105 Reviews

“The team at Fred Hamilton Allstate Insurance are so helpful and attentive. They are available to answer any questions and so pleasant to work with. I am happy to work with them for my insurance needs.”

5 Superb95 Reviews

“It was a pleasure discussing and arranging the insurance with Marykate Sluka. Marykate was a good part of the reason why we are coming back to Edward Lehmann and Allstate. Being able to talk with responsible and reasonable people makes all the difference.”

5 Superb99 Reviews

“I had an excellent experience working with Jazline. From the very beginning she was patient, knowledgeable, and incredibly helpful in guiding me through the process of obtaining insurance. She took the time to explain every detail clearly, answered all of my questions, and made sure I felt supported and guided every step of the way. Their professionalism and dedication truly stood out. What could have been a stressful process became smooth and straightforward because of her assistance. I’m extremely grateful for her help and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable and personalized service. Jazline really took a lot of weight off my shoulders and I will definitely be recommending her to anyone looking for any type of insurance.”

4.9 Superb121 Reviews

“Lydia very respectful, helpful and professional. Sounded in awesome mood when I spoke with her on the phone. Keep up the great work. Happy Thanksgiving to all of you????”

4.9 Superb100 Reviews

“I called their office while I was feeling very desperate. I had made up my mind that if I couldn't find insurance at a reasonable price, I would sell my car. The cost of insurance for a student who has just moved to New York is astronomical.
Zulma Guarda gave me excellent advice with great patience and introduced me to every option that could help me save money on my car insurance. I am grateful to her for all her help.”

4.9 Superb104 Reviews

“I have been working with Deann in Sean Mcarthy State Farm Insurance since I was single until got married we have 2 kids and they are grown up already and still with this . Co because Deann is always good with the customer very pleasant, helpful, reliable , , happy all the time to answer any questions when you call for questions always have an answer and good suggestion always trying to save you money, I’m with this co for 2 decades already for auto insurance and then bought a house of course we called Deann for homeowner insurance you will build a friendship relationship that’s how happy we are with Deann Thank you so much Deann always nice talking to you !!”

4.9 Superb91 Reviews

“This was my first time getting my own insurance. Nestor did an amazing job with helping me out to get the best price. Nestor got me less than half of what other insurance companies were quoting me. I appreciate this guy and highly recommend using him and his services. Thank you for your amazing help!”

4.9 Superb76 Reviews

“Cindy along with all the staff from State Farm are amazing! Super knowledgeable, easy to work with, and always quick to respond. They make the insurance process simple and stress-free. Highly recommend this office!”

4.9 Superb85 Reviews

“My only go to for dmv services.
aaa members get this perk.
super clean and super nice people.
days of dealing with rude dmv staff and long lines is OVER.
THANK YOU AAA.”

4.8 Superb165 Reviews

“Very professional and caring Insurance Agency. The owner, Robert Zabbia and his staff especially the Office Manager Denise provide excellent service. Even with escalating insurance premiums, they will work very hard to get you the best premium for the best coverage. The Zabbia Agency has been my Insurance agency for over 15 years.”

4.9 Superb66 Reviews

“Steven has been an incredible auto insurance agent! He’s knowledgeable, responsive, and truly cares about his clients. He always takes the time to explain things clearly and makes sure I’m getting the best coverage for my needs.

It’s rare to find someone so professional and genuine. I highly recommend Steven to anyone looking for an agent who truly goes above and beyond!”

4.9 Superb74 Reviews

“I just want to start off by saying that Linda is my agent and she went up and beyond to make sure I had insurance. She was absolutely amazing... if it wasn't for her staying after work, to make sure that I had a policy, I would not have insurance right now ... like I said she is a true Godsend ... thank you so much, Ms. Linda. I am truly one satisfied customer.”

4.8 Superb111 Reviews

“Thanks to Brandon Schlott, we feel very good about our decision to choose Allstate for our Home and Auto insurance, especially confident knowing Brandon Schlott is there to advise and help when necessary.”

5 Superb47 Reviews

“We have been with this agency for over 35 years. The staff is great and always helps us with anything related to our policies. Allstate is the best company as well.”

4.9 Superb61 Reviews

“Dear State Farm Team,

I am writing to recognize the exceptional service I consistently receive from your representative, Karen. I called just to get a car insurance quote for my daughter with the 1(800) number, but Karen went far beyond their service. She took the time to listen, thoroughly explain our options, and help us clear up a misunderstanding we had regarding coverage for my daughter.
Her professionalism, patience, and genuine willingness to assist turned what could have been a stressful situation into an easy and reassuring experience. Because of Karen’s stellar support, we feel confident, respected, and truly valued as State Farm customers.
I wanted to be sure her efforts are acknowledged. Karen is the reason we are proud and happy to remain with State Farm.

Thank you”

4.9 Superb69 Reviews

“I recently switched to State Farm for my car insurance, and I couldn't be happier with my decision. From the start, Marcela Ruppert customer service was exceptional. The representative Joe Q. I spoke with was knowledgeable, patient and took the time to explain all the coverage options available to me.

They have a fast response time when emailing with questions, competitive rates and offer discounts.

Overall, I highly recommend State Farm for anyone looking for reliable and affordable car insurance. Their excellent customer service and comprehensive coverage options make them a top choice in my book.”

5 Superb45 Reviews

“My family has been working with Bob and John for over 20 years. We appreciate all the the support they have given us over the years for all the issues that we run into. We feel that we can count on them for all the twists that life throws our way. I highly recommend them if you are looking for insurance.”

4.9 Superb56 Reviews

“After switching to State Farm my car was hit, the staff talked me through the whole procedure alleviating my worry and fears( first accident in 70 years, and not my fault). The staff is extremely friendly and knowledgeable. The prices are very reasonable also”

5 Superb42 Reviews

“Ive been shopping for insurance since yesterday. I was shot down by geico, progressive and every other place i could possibly call in a day. Today while my wife was getting an inspection done on her vehicle at Midas, I randomly walked into an Allstate office on sunrise hwy in seaford ny…. I walked in with ZERO expectations on getting a quote. I explained my situation to the lovely ladies at the office and I have to say.. LUCY PATTERSON!!! Omg!! Heaven sent!! She sat at that computer and vigorously punched at that keyboard with no concern for her manicured fingers and gave me the ABSOLUTE best quote which I ultimately believed was impossible!!! I walked out of that office with my head held high and an insured vehicle!!! Thank you so much Lucy! God bless you!!!!’”

4.9 Superb42 Reviews

“This is a small neighborhood business with big capabilities and awesome service. I’ve been dealing with Denise and Mecola for years and can’t say enough about their professionalism and service! Whenever I have questions or need to change things on my auto, home or motorcycle policies, I get IMMEDIATE ASSISTANCE - and it’s done right the first time every time! They really care about what they do and are good at it! They take a personal interest in my family and our needs. The best in the business! I’m happy to recommend this fine company.”

5 Superb32 Reviews

“I am immensely grateful for the incredible support and assistance provided by Christina Shaw from The Shaw Agency during an incredibly challenging time for my family.
Christina showed a level of compassion that my family will be forever grateful for. She took the time to reach out on countless occasions to follow up and keep us in her thoughts a prayers as the claims process worked itself out. More importantly she set aside her time to take my kids to a local toy store and treating them as members of her own family even introducing us to her own daughters and making us feel a level of comfort after losing everything in a tragic house fire one week before Christmas.
Christina stepped in with compassion, expertise, and a level of dedication that exceeded all expectations. She not only guided us through the insurance claims process with efficiency and clarity but also offered genuine empathy and support during our darkest days.
What truly distinguishes The Shaw agency is their unwavering commitment to their clients' well-being. They treated us not just as customers, but as individuals deserving of personalized care and attention. Their kindness and understanding meant the world to us during a period of immense hardship.
I cannot recommend The Shaw Agency highly enough. If you are seeking an insurance broker who not only excels in their profession but also genuinely cares about their clients' welfare, look no further. Christina and her staff set the standard for exceptional service and compassion in the insurance industry.
Thank you, Christina, for your outstanding support and for going above and beyond to help my family when we needed it most. Your dedication and kindness will always be remembered. Not only do I consider you an exceptional person, but I consider you a member of my family and a friend for life. Thank you again for all that you have done and for going that extra mile for my family.”

4.8 Superb58 Reviews

“Anthony at the office has been handling my insurance for about 10 years and he is always very helpful and eager to answer any questions I might have. He’s helped with my homeowners policy and automobile policy and also other things like life insurance and umbrella policies in the past. I always recommend Anthony and the Jim Tomeo Allstate office whenever I hear that someone is having issues with insurance.”

5 Superb30 Reviews

“Not only am I personally insured by Statefarm, I also work for a company who is insured by Statefarm so I speak to them on a regular basis. From the beginning Isabella and Norma have been my go-to girls for all my insurance needs. They are always willing and able to help when needed and I couldn't be more grateful for such an amazing team. Thank you both so much.”

4.7 Superb72 Reviews

“Excellent service, the staff is very prepared, not to mention the agent Ricardo Mercado, a very kind person, prepared and above all, an excellent human being.Excellent service, the staff is very prepared, and not to mention the agent Ricardo Mercado, a very friendly, prepared person and above all an excellent human being”

4.9 Superb31 Reviews