Finger Lakes Premier Properties is the largest Short-Term Property Management Company in the Finger Lakes Region, specializing in Lakefront Vacation Rentals and Real Estate Sales across six lakes: Canandaigua, Cayuga, Conesus, Honeoye, Keuka, and Seneca. They manage over 280 long and short-term rentals, providing a range of services including 24/7 guest and owner support, housekeeping, maintenance, marketing, and accounting. Reviewers consistently praise the company for its superior service compared to platforms like Airbnb or VRBO, highlighting the personal communication from staff before, during, and after stays. Guests appreciate the clean, updated homes and the quick response to any issues. The properties, such as Black Dog's Bluff on Keuka Lake, are noted for their immaculate condition, spaciousness, and beautiful views, making them ideal for gatherings and vacations. Additionally, the real estate team is recognized for their expertise in Lakefront Properties, with agents like Brian receiving high commendations for their knowledge, negotiation skills, and patience, making the buying experience smooth for clients. Overall, Finger Lakes Premier Properties is highly recommended for anyone looking for a memorable vacation rental or real estate opportunities in the Finger Lakes Region.
Have rented from this company three times and have always had excellent service. Every home we have rented were exceptionally clean and had everything we needed.
July 2025
My family and I have been renting Keuka Lake houses through Premier Properties for many many years. We were very pleased with their services and units. The one time that we did have an issue, the Management reached out and made things right. Very pleased to do business with them. Thank You Amy!
May 2025
We have enjoyed working with Brain. He is very knowledgeable about finger lake areas. He has a talent in negotiation and communication with buyers and sellers. We are so grateful for his effort and patience. We highly recommend him!
