24HR Fuel Available Crosby’s is your local family-owned convenience store and gas station, proudly serving communities across NY & PA. Offering oven-fresh pizza slices, quality fuel, and more— Crosby’s has everything you need! Stop in store now or order online!
The subway inside was an odd experience, but the Crosby cashier was nice!
May 2026
Great for snacks, soda, pizza, also a subway here, need gas 5hey have it.
May 2026
Ordered 1 large pepperoni and cheese with regular sauce and 1 large pepperoni and cheese with white garlic sauce. Pizza was undercooked and the garlic sauce pizza was missing pepperoni with the paper saying it had pepperoni on it.
