-
March 2024 by James Hybicki
Best time in a long time !! We were heading to Elmira for a hockey game and randomly chose the lumber yard for a late lunch early dinner, We got there around 2 on a Saturday. The waitress, Chris was great , very friendly, very informative . The food was excellent I had the big cut of prime rib, no bone , hardly any fat just meat ! My son had the biggest juiceous wings and wife had the chicken and artichoke , all unbelievably delicious!! The salad bar was how a salad bar should be , all fresh , assortment of toppings and dressings . I Also partaked in some of the ribs and at a buck apiece at early bird time , delicious, so much food we took home left overs that were eaten the next day . This joint is about a hour and a half from our house but we will be taking a drive to go back for sure . I would highly recommend this restaurant , it has an old school vibe to it with unbelievable food and service!!
-
March 2024 by Bob Johnson
Very disappointed in our dinner been coming here for 35+ years and have always had the casinos and stuffed shrimp on the menu I would of at least hoped you would of posted that your menu has changed.always new it was more expensive then it should be but most of the time it was enjoyable tonight's meal was not worth $150 that's for sure prime rib was barely warm and tough and stuffed haddock had no flavor its always the same,new people take over and change things up it usually doesn't end well good luck in the future we will be going past to perry to yard of ale in geneseo from now on
-
March 2024 by Ian Houlihan
The price of the meals where a little more than expected. The food was good but I have had better.Parking: Out back behind the restaurantWheelchair accessibility: Not vary there are a few tables that a wheelchair can access witch is only 20% of the restaurant
-
February 2024 by Rob G
The bartender was excellent, the appetizer was delicious, and the atmosphere was good.
-
February 2024 by Joyce Brown
Very nice place to
-
January 2024 by Kelly Harrison
The Lumber Yard does not disappoint. Everything is amazing. Salad bar is fresh, menu has a more than ample selection. Reasonable prices.
-
January 2024 by T.J. Gullo
Went for a work gathering. The service was wonderful, and the prime rib is excellent! Definitely want to go back again. The salad bar and French onion soup are great,
-
January 2024 by John Rauber
The soup and salad bar by itself is a little pricey, and the soups that I tried were very salty but if you get any other food it was amazing some of the best prime rib I ever had and the fish fry was huge so overall it is a definite one I will be back
-
January 2024 by ERICA E
Great food, friendly staff.
-
January 2024 by gary h
This is a good solid American restaurant. It has a nice appearance and feel inside - the atmosphere is good. It smells great as a mix of seafood and beef. The service was excellent. The salad bar and drinks are also excellent. There are a few minor things that need tending to with regard to the food. For example, the bread came cold. I had parmesan encrusted scallops which came floating in a lemon oil sauce that I believe was supposed to pass for a lemon butter sauce. It was okay but not great - next time, the broiled scallops. My wife had the parmesan encrusted scallops and a 10 oz slice of prime rib which was kind of tough but still tasty. The desserts are not made on the premises. While the cost is not exorbitant, it is still substantial. As such, it demands that the minor issues with the food be corrected.
-
January 2024 by Lorie Ames
Highly recommend for a fine dining
-
January 2024 by Dustin Curry
Hands down the best Rib and seafood dinner I have eaten.
-
January 2024 by Arionna Goodenow
It was an amazing experience eating here, definitely going here again. The food and the service was
-
November 2023 by La Nissa Dyman
Prime Rib........need I say more. ? The service was the best part. Beautiful restaurant, cozy environment. Clean facilities. Plenty of space for a large party or a romantic table setting for 2. Options for kids. Fresh salad bar and delicious Homemade soups. Oh and HIGHLY recommended the lemon blueberry cake!
-
October 2023 by Bess Jones
Quaint place with interesting history. Loved the atmosphere. Chicken Neptune was very good and fresh. Salad bar had nice selection, fresh. Haylee was awesome. Very personable, friendly and answered our questions about when it was an actual lumber yard! Loved it.
