Jewelry Stores in Port Jefferson, NY

“First time visiting the store. Needed a replacement battery for my watch. The owner Chris was very nice, professional and expedient in providing service. The price was very reasonable. I was surprised that it wasn't much higher. The store is nice with various items good for gifting. It's eclectic. Has incense, porcelain items, jewelry (more for women than men), etc. Great place to get a gift that is reasonable in price esp these days. Definitely recommend and will return.”

“Very nice gentleman. Interesting variety of products, from clothing to lighting to artwork to, well, all sorts of stuff. He held a wind chime I ordered and was unable to get back for much longer than most retailers would have. Nice place. Check it out.”

“Booked the In-Store Color Analysis for my mom for her birthday. Such a great gift idea! She absolutely loved it. Turns out she's a Cool Summer and is looking forward to redoing her whole wardrobe. She said it was informative, fun and gave her a new sense of confidence. Can't wait to try it for myself.”

“Never thought about leaving this place a review till now, but I can't wait to return (Only visit LI once a year, grew up in Valley Stream, but I live in NV) next year because I should've bought more stickers to decorate my vehicle (Thought I bought enough but it turns out I did not) and I do need more.

They sell awesome strong waterproof stickers and they stick and stay on your vehicle (Even through heavy rain showers and whenever you go to a car wash) unlike ones I've bought online and very few sellers on eBay sell the same brand of stickers they do. Highly recommend their stickers located in their revolving rack if your looking into decorating your vehicle with stickers without worrying about them getting ruined or peeling off cause they are indeed WATERPROOF AND STRONG.”

“I live this shop and Susan's the best. I have purchased several of her personal designs, and beyond being beautiful, she creates them from the soul, with love. I look forward to seeing her each time I'm in Port Jeff. Thanks Susan!”

“What an absolute gem of a store! We were visiting family in New York from Colorado and decided to stop into PJ Vintage while we were in Port Jefferson. The store has such a fun and unique selection, the prices are very reasonable, and the entire experience was genuinely enjoyable.

A huge part of what made our visit so special was Stacy! She was incredibly friendly, welcoming, helpful, and just an absolute pleasure to talk with. She took the time to help my daughter look through different options, and thanks to Stacy, my daughter actually found her prom dress! ❤ We definitely weren’t expecting to come home from our trip to New York with a prom dress, which made the experience even more memorable.

Stacy made us feel like we were shopping with a friend rather than just visiting a store. If you’re in Port Jefferson, PJ Vintage is absolutely worth stopping into. There are so many unique finds, great prices, and wonderful customer service. Thank you, Stacy, for making our visit from Colorado one we’ll always remember!”