Kirwan's Game Store is a cool, well-stocked game shop in the Hudson Valley with a friendly and knowledgeable staff. The store is packed with everything from card games, board games, and manga to comics, minis, accessories, collectibles, and new releases. Its layout is clean, organized, and easy to browse, making the experience relaxing and fun. The staff is laid-back, patient, and incredibly helpful, whether explaining rules to new players, answering questions, or giving honest recommendations. They host various weekly events and additional events for new product releases. The store has a trade-in policy offering 50% of market value in store credit, which some customers find extremely fair, though others feel the percentage is low. Sealed products like new Pokémon sets are sometimes sold at market price, which is reasonably priced for presale events. The store community is generally welcoming, with players enjoying card games there regularly. However, some casual Commander players express frustration with others using highly competitive or "toxic" decks in casual settings. Overall, Kirwan's is considered a gem and is highly recommended for collectors, casual gamers, and those shopping for gifts, providing a fun and welcoming environment for the community.
Nice store good games. Friendly staff I play card games here all the time after my wife left me and married my sister’s husband. 😊
February 2026
I visited this place while on a ski trip away from home and as nice as the store is, it's just really upsetting to have Commander players with their sweat decks all the time. Nobody wants to see you diddle yourself with toxic cards. Someone was playing Sunder the other day... This is casual Commander bro. Go do that somewhere... read full comment
January 2026
Comic and model kit prices were awesome for a mall. Figures were pricier.
