Great American is a small, family-owned grocery store with a long-standing presence in the community, now in its fourth generation. It offers a neat and clean shopping environment, with friendly staff who provide great customer service. The store features a variety of products, including a small deli and manager's specials, making it a convenient place for everyday shopping. Parking is ample, and the store is located near a park with a pavilion, adding to its appeal. While some mention that prices used to be better and that the store is not very close to their homes, many appreciate the quality and freshness of the items, as well as the time and gas saved compared to larger supermarkets far away. Customers often feel a strong sense of loyalty and enjoyment, describing their visits as more than just shopping — some express love for the store, comparing it favorably to bigger stores or even likening it to a special experience. Despite occasional personal stories, the overall sentiment highlights the store’s friendly atmosphere, neatness, and the welcoming vibe that keeps customers returning regularly.
Best store in the area, they have everything and Jim is great!
January 2026
Nice folks and staff is helpful. Cashiers have been pleasant too. Well stocked and a nice walk-in adult beverage cooler at the back. They even posts their weekly flyer on fb social media.
November 2025
Great food market hidden in the catskill mountains that I go to whenever visiting the area. Deli and meat prices are very reasonable. Folks there are super helpful and friendly,
