Talmage Farm Agway is a well-regarded store located in the Riverhead mall area, known for its extensive range of products for those who embrace a backyard country lifestyle. The store offers everything from lawn and garden supplies to beekeeping equipment, poultry supplies, and pet food. Customers appreciate the knowledgeable and friendly staff, who consistently provide helpful service, whether it’s assisting with specific needs or recommending products. Shoppers have noted that the store is more agriculturally focused compared to other Agway locations, making it a go-to destination for backyard farmers. The inventory is well-stocked, and if an item is not on display, staff members are willing to check the backroom for availability. Prices may be slightly higher, but an unadvertised senior citizen discount is available on select days. Overall, Talmage Farm Agway is praised for its excellent customer service and comprehensive product offerings, making it a highly recommended one-stop shop for gardening, farming, and pet needs in the area.
Was an excellent experience. Sherry and her employee at the register treated me to a very enjoyable shopping experience. Looking forward to returning to Agway, a unique & gorgeous store.
May 2026
I rented a U-Haul truck from there. The process was quick and seamless
April 2026
Small store that carries it all. Very knowledgeable staff
