-
March 2024 by Gabe D.
Paid 25$ for a large at latta/Flynn and it wasn't even cooked. Won't be going back for that price.
-
February 2024 by Hannah Peritore
This is our go-to pizza spot for the area. Love the pizza AND the wings are great too! Really superior to all the other pizza places nearby.Parking: Plenty of parking in the lot, plus a few pickup only spots right in front.
-
February 2024 by Alec Iovino
As a business owner, I understand the significance of making informed choices post an error. Ordered over the phone a spinach and artichoke pizza, which is not listed as a specialty pizza on the website. I, like many others, would assume spinach and artichoke is made using white garlic sauce. Since this is not a specialty menu item, I should have been asked what sauce was preferred, if white garlic is not the default choice. No clarifying questions were asked regarding sauce choice and I received the pizza with red sauce. After expressing my concerns over the phone, I was informed “that’s how we do it,” and received no resolution or compensation for their error/lack of communication. I conveyed my decision to cease patronage if this was the extent of their “customer service,” and the response I got was a casual "have a good night." It's crucial to invest in businesses that appreciate your patronage and address issues promptly. I won't be making future orders from them.
-
February 2024 by Krystal Volpe
Ordered a sub and the bread was burnt
-
January 2024 by Kevin Lyons
Best pizza in
-
January 2024 by Hydra Mulan Baloi
Che Buonae! ?????Vegetarian options: *** Friendly and knowledgeable staff with a sizeable range for their rewards program to be affordable on a budget. ***
-
January 2024 by Thomas Reddick
The atmosphere is only a two stars because you pick your pizza up there and you leave. There's not much to it. The service is on par with the food for me. The pizza used to be too greasy, but the more you eat it the more you like the grease. So there's that. The pizza does taste pretty good though.
-
December 2023 by Emily Waite
Don’t order door dash here, on two occasions, the delivery’s ended up being totally wrong or messed up. I know it’s not all their fault but the fault of the door dash employee, however, they don’t put names/receipts on the package and they don’t tape it up to prevent items being touched or falling out. Dont use door dash from this place!!!!!
-
December 2023 by Lamar Burrows
The pizza was just OK for me. Ordered a sheet Pepperoni and 24 wings to feed the kids and grands and it hot thr job done but I've had much better pizza.
-
December 2023 by Brian K.
Placed a large order for a school in Greece for delivery at 12:00pm. We make this order every year for a Holiday party, and the previous year the delivery was 30 mins late, so this year I specifically requested delivery at 12:00pm, which I was guaranteed by the Latta Rd store that would not be a problem. So 12:00pm noon comes and goes, so I call the Latta Rd store at 12:20pm. Apparently they saved the wrong number for me and could not call to tell me that they didn't realize they didn't have a delivery driver at that location for a noon delivery. They sent the order to the N. Greece Rd store. I called the N. Greece Rd store, now its 12:30pm, and was told they also tried to call me but had the wrong number, oh and that one of the Big Tony's I ordered got stuck in the oven, and that when the delivery driver returned they would be sending the order over....it's now 12:40pm and the kids leave in 15 mins. The pizza and cold wings arrived at 12:50pm. So needless to say, won't be using Caraglio's for our school orders or personal orders either. They were very apologetic and gave us a discount, but 2 years in a row....not waiting for strike 3. Sorry.
-
December 2023 by C S.
Oder number OLO24. Placed order at 5:02 pm, with deliver for 6:15 pm. Called Fairport location at 6:35 pm to check on order. They hung up the phone and I had to call back. Was told my delivery would be 10 minutes. Pizza came at 6:55 pm and it was cold. Thought I'd give this place a try, but back to Mark's Pizza in the future.
-
November 2023 by Snake Doc
Don't offer curbside pick up on your website if your employees are too lazy to perform the
-
October 2023 by K Fras
You have to ask for the thin crust, otherwise you get a loaf of bread with sauce and cheese. If that's your thing don't ask for thin. Overall they have a really good sauce, and don't typically over cheese.Typically it's cut
-
October 2023 by Matt Vogel
Pizza is not good. Buffalo sauce in not traditional it is a version that is very different from traditional Buffalo hot or mild and disappointing. Total waste of money.
-
October 2023 by Toijah
Caraglio's pizza ? is good. But I haven't tried out there Italian sausage yet.
