-
October 2023 by Josh Tierney
Not open
-
October 2022 by Ethan Bennett
Coleman's name has been synonymous with top notch fly fishing expertise in the Rochester area for many years. I made a special trip over an hour to visit the shop and was surprised to see that his shop was closed, despite business hours stating the shop was open online. Don't be fooled he is appointment only, presumably due to the owner's older age and health.When I called the number, Carl gruffly stated he was unable to accommodate my request to find a few fly tying hooks and materials, which seemed unreasonable as the store specializes in fly fishing. For a shop as renowned in the area as Coleman's I have to say I was fairly disappointed by the owners gusto to help an avid college fly fisherman, and even more surprised when I was refered to a big box store to find such supplies.
-
October 2022 by Jed Ilgenfritz
Carl was able and happy to answer all my questions. His decades of experience clearly demonstrate his expertise on any fly fishing in Upstate New York. I will definitely be visiting next time I'm in the area!
-
February 2019 by Kevin Macnaughton
Yes Paul Newman himself would be stoked
