-
February 2024 by Wired With Walsh
Nowadays I don’t often eat pizza but when I do I have a few choices in the area and I always come back to this one. The hours are good they’re open late and the pizzas always really good the quality is consistent. I find that the cheese they use must be good or high quality than most other local pizzerias because it melts and pulls really well. They have a lot of specialty slices including barbecue chicken and Buffalo chicken slices for sure always very nice. They’re crispy crust really stands out on their Sicilian and square slices. Their Zucchini Sicilian slices really nice. They have a full menu with plenty of room in the back to eat. You can even take your slices back there and eat in silence for the most part it’s very nice. The staff here are super friendly as well.
-
February 2024 by thomas stewart
Awesome pizza ?
-
January 2024 by Melissa Walker-Nwazu
I had to try it 3 too confirm that I wasn't hungry ,I've tried it when I was hungry and I tried it when I was just craving pizza. let me tell you guys I have not been disappointed not once even late night. It has been delicious some of the best pizza I've ever had. I like the Margarita. It puts me somewhere in Italy it's just delicious. I forgot to add I do not eat out And I'm also a culinary arts professional so well, that's a the food is good, Oh it's goooood.Vegetarian options: Yummy
-
January 2024 by Dmitriy Rusachev
Bad place, you guys don't know how to cook pizza. You had to re-hire those guys from Giro's pizza on Beach 116 street before they closed. You remind me another bad place on Cross bay blvd. Those pizzas also claim they are the best pizza. Second is price. You charge $5.50 per slice, ok I gave you $6, I didn't see any attempt to give me 50 cents back, I will live it to you, but you took it like an amount due! I will continue attack you under different name to reduce you to dirt.5 stars NEGATIVE!
-
January 2024 by Jerusha Jones
Pizza is not good like it use to be... And much smaller than before ?
-
December 2023 by Neil Walsh
Very solid place overall. I like their plain slice and their specialties as well. I go to this place a few times a month and always enjoy the food.
-
October 2023 by Eduardo Varas
Got a vegetable pie, a grandma slice and a plain slice. Totally delicious. Super friendly on phone, very fast friendly delivery.
-
October 2023 by Mike S.
If you find yourself in Rockaway and are looking for a great slice (or pie) of old school NY pizza, give Pizza D'Amore a tryI grew up here but moved away nearly 40 years ago, so all my old favorites are either gone or under new ownership. I tried this one 7 years ago with my dad when I was home for a school reunion. On this trip for his funeral, I got a pie for the family for dinner Just cheese like a classic NY pie should be. Sauce was mildly sweet and the crust was crispy and perfect This will be my go-to pizzeria whenever I come back to visit from now on!
-
September 2023 by Denise Himmel
Horrible! Pizza was super thin, sauce was spicy..very disappointed that I paid over $20 of a pizza that was tasteless and spicy!
-
September 2023 by shaunatrouble Murphy
Tasty pizza. Nice crust, flavorful sauce, and great mozzarella. Recomend!
-
September 2023 by Marie Headley
The Food is inconsistent. Sometimes their Pizza is lip smacking Delicious and other times it’s a Horrible Burned on the bottom dry piece of cardboard. The Customer service is Bad from one guy in particular, I don’t know his name but he’s a tall Spanish guy whom somehow thinks he’s Italian and he has a Huge chip on his shoulder, He’s just plain rude. I’ll Never go to that Pizzeria again. I rather spend more money buying from The Brisa Del Mar across the street…. At least the food there is ALWAYS Delicious ?
-
September 2023 by Itsmenana_98 :}
Absolutely ?? love there pizza ?. It’s made very fresh and they have a variety of toppings !!!
-
August 2023 by Lucy
After a long day in the beach, with two hungry little kids, the pizza tasted so good. My favorite was the thick slice with chicken and bacon. The sicilian slice was also delicous. The place is not that big, but when we visited it was just right. Prices are more or less ok. Service was also on point.Wheelchair accessibility: Anybody in weelchair would be able to enjoy pizza here.
-
August 2023 by natasha polanco
They have really good, delicious pizza. They're always busy, so they're always making fresh food.
-
July 2023 by Mad Tricarico
I sent my husband to get a calzone he came back with this huge 16 inch cold mess. It was burnt on the outside and a cold mess in the inside. The ricotta cheesecheese was a cold mess, no flavor and the mozzarella cheese was fake. I was very disappointed. Doesn't anyone know how to cook any more. I would have loved to have a smaller one that was made with flavor and with real cheese and cost the same amount. The pizza ? was not good either he asked for sausage and peppers on a slice and that was disappointing too. We tried to support our local restaurants but. This is hard when you can't enjoy something that shouldn't be so hard to make. All I can say is if you want to stay in business don't make big size looking food that is made with fake ingredient, make smaller portions of quality food with flavor and people will come back for more!!!!