-
November 2025 by James Rada
We saw that they had gotten high ratings, so we visited for a wine tasting. If you look at many of the positive reviews, they're for something else other than the wine. We agree and we understand why. Normally when we do a wine tasting, we can find at least one wine that we like and will buy a bottle to take home. Not at Buttonwood. Their wines taste nothing like the description and, to be honest, it doesn't matter. They just weren't any good. Compared to the better Finger Lakes wineries, they're not even close.
-
October 2025 by L Anderson
I was surprised that we had to do our tasting out of the same glass. I didn’t care for one of my choices, so didn’t finish it. When the server came around for the 2nd pour, she told me I had to drink up in order to get the next taste. It was a bit startling. I suppose I could have asked for a fresh glass but the “tone” of the server didn’t lend to asking. I will applaud the option for gluten free crackers as one of our guests requires that.
-
October 2025 by Tom Robinson
The best winery on Cayuga Lake!!
-
October 2025 by Rachel Stewart
Bonnie was such a doll! The wine is fabulous and the winery is one of the most beautiful in the area.
-
October 2025 by Cory Balliet
The wines here is excellent! I tried a good variety of wines, some Dry some sweet, not a bad one in the bunch. I think my favorite was the Sauvignon Blanc. One thing that really stood out to me, is their tasting notes on their menu were spot on, which is super helpful for folks like me who aren't wine experts.
-
October 2025 by P. S. Murray
Excellent wine. Good service on the porch.
-
October 2025 by Andrew Bromley
I did a blind tasting with Bonnie. I did a terrible time guessing the wines, but it was a ton of fun, and the wines were all lovely. Bonnie made me feel right at home, and she seemed to enjoy picking out wines that might stump me. Whether you do a blind tasting or a traditional one, I highly recommend putting this on your list.
-
October 2025 by Tamara Mitchell
Always a fun tasting experience. We love having June as our server. She’s knowledgeable and super sweet.
Nice range of wines with something for every taste.
-
October 2025 by brenda santos
Had a great time at your winery
-
October 2025 by Ann Marie Kennedy
Wonderful tasting experience. Highly recommend! Dora was friendly, knowledgeable and excited about the wines, which we thoroughly enjoyed. Will definitely return.
-
October 2025 by Maureen Rath
Amazing winery! Diana was extremely knowledgeable and made our experience so enjoyable. Wines were delicious ...Buttonwood is the best hidden gem of the Finger Lakes! Gorgeous views, beautiful indoor and outdoor spaces, fantastic tasting experience! Highly recommend!!
-
September 2025 by Caroline Simock
Beautiful surroundings, quiet
-
September 2025 by Karen
I would highly recommend a stay here. Visited the winery last year (delicious wines) and decided to try the cabin this year. Had a lovely view of Cayuga Lake from our front porch in the cabin. The cabin was very clean and very customer friendly with a small fridge, Keurig coffee maker, coffee, sugar, creamers, microwave, toaster oven, television, & Wi-Fi. Even though there are four cabins near one another and they were all occupied, you had privacy and didn't interfere with each other. They also supplied wood for a pitfire which we thoroughly enjoyed during our stay. The staff was very friendly and customer oriented. We are looking forward to a return visit!
-
September 2025 by Melissa
Great wine! Service is awesome. I became a wine club member because it’s my favorite winery🥂
-
September 2025 by Syd Ross
Love this winery and love being a wine club member! The wines are very good and the service is fantastic. Stephanie is our favorite customer service representative! She took amazing care of us this past Monday. Went back yesterday and Laura did i nice job too. Hoping for one more visit before we leave the area. I love how they serve cheese and bread or gluten free crackers with every tasting. Nice touch! We do not stay there but stay near thank goodness!
