Sag Harbor Liquor Store is known for its friendly and caring service. One customer praised Hilary for going above and beyond by arranging a special delivery of a bottle to a wedding on Shelter Island, showing genuine thoughtfulness and humanity. Another visitor appreciated the simple, quick process of buying a specific rosé wine, with no ID required and a fair price. The store also received high marks for its helpful staff, with Nicole assisting a customer in finding a great Cabernet and answering questions patiently. Additionally, the store offers convenient services like gift wrapping and delivery, making it easy to send gifts like whiskey for special occasions. Overall, Sag Harbor Liquor Store provides a great selection of drinks and excellent customer service, making it a favorite spot for both locals and visitors.
Best selection of rose wine anywhere I've found, great liquor store!
June 2024
Stopped by looking for a specific bottle rosé wine. I was never asked to present an ID and was simply asked if I’m over 21. Life is good indeed. I paid $30 and I was on my mary way.
November 2023
The best experience! I wanted to send my husband an anniversary gift of nice whiskey while he was away for work, and the shop went above and beyond to make that happen. Not only was it fast and easy, but she gift wrapped it for me beautifully and delivered it. So nice! Thank you!
