Sag Harbor Variety Store is a nostalgic five and dime store on Long Island that has hardly changed over the years. It offers a wide range of last-minute items, including games, toys, bespoke sodas, candy, kitchenware, and beach necessities. While some customers find the prices a bit high, they appreciate the unique items and support the family-owned business. The staff is described as wonderful by many, although some reviews mention unfriendly service. Overall, it's a place with a rich history and a diverse selection.
I always love shopping here when I'm visiting family in Springs. They have a LOT packed into a smallish store and its really fun to check out all the aisles for household needs and fun treasures. My m.i.l. bought some fabric and the woman working in the fabric area was delightful and helpful.
September 2025
A little bit of everything - great staff and fair prices. Old tiney vibe!
August 2024
This place has hardly changed since I was a kid. It has all the last minute items you forgot you needed plus more. From games and toys, to bespoke sodas and candy, to kitchen ware and beach necessities, this place probably has what you need
