-
March 2024 by Natalie H
Great place to eat, friendly staff, delicious food, cute atmosphere.
-
March 2024 by LAS2
Fire oven....quick....get there before the oven is turned into electric! Best pizza. Extreme flavor that comes from wood fired ovens. Just a fact. Apologies for being political.
-
February 2024 by Simon Perschbacher
No complaints! Absolutely amazing pizza and very friendly
-
February 2024 by Matt Don
Excellent pizza and top notch friendly service. We had the Neapolitan as well as the Sicilian pizza. Both were fresh and delicious. Family and child friendly. Highly recommended.
-
January 2024 by Nicolas Hoyos
Table service is quite sub par.
-
January 2024 by Duane Watkins
My wife and I came out from Oyster Bay.Order a couple slices. The slices were burnt.Then another pizza was made to replace the slices... Everything was raw. The assistant pointed it out to the cook. He shrugged it off.We took 2 bites and threw them in the trash.Other people were also unhappy and complained about there meals..The food didn't look good...
-
January 2024 by Dan Sullivan
Pizza was insanely soggy and floppy. Never eating here again.
-
January 2024 by Kaitlin Callahan
This place is actually so nasty. Everything was extremely lackluster and pretty much tasteless. The burrata tasted like nothing, kale seemed unwashed, pizza was really bad, sprite tasted flat and old, flies were everywhere. I had the highest expectations coming here and I left extremely disappointed. Prices are ridiculous too. Do yourself a favor and go literally anywhere else in Sag.
-
January 2024 by John Robinson
Honestly the hype around this place is a complete lie. I have been excited to try this place for years but was so let down when we finally went. The whole thing was incredibly gross especially for the the prices they have. The pizza was gross and lackluster, tasted worse than a frozen pizza from a grocery store. The burrata was boring, no taste, bad bread. The salad was so bad, horrible dressing. On top of that the place was crawling with bugs. The bugs were all over the food, all over the table, and flying in your face the whole time. Do not believe the reviews this place is not worth it at all.
-
January 2024 by Gabriella Sobanski
Okay so I got too excited eating the apps to get a picture before, but you can see the perfect pizza pies!!! We walked in to Sag Pizza on a chilly day and were instantly warmed by the amazing food and friendly atmosphere. The burrata, chopped Arthur, and meatballs were all fantastic. I’m not a big salad person, but I could eat this stuff every day. As for the pizzas, we had the San marzano, vongole (both pictured) and the pepperoni. All of them were delicious and we got three dippers along with them. Pro tip: pour the hot honey on the pepperoni for pure perfection.I would highly recommend this place it’s a perfect location on Main Street, pretty affordable, and delicious with a friendly staff. Come here you won’t regret it!Parking: Only restaurant with a parking lot in Sag Harbor!
-
January 2024 by Hagen Reams
This was my first trip to the state of New York. Started in NYC and ended our trip in Sag Harbor. Out of the 5 pizza places I went to Sag Pizza had the best pizza. The pepperonis were perfect, cheese was delicious, crust had the exact amount of crisp I like. But not only the pizza….the meatballs….mmm delicious. Also try out the Sag Pizza Lager, smooth, refreshing and everything you’d want in a beer.
-
January 2024 by Lachlan Miles
They forgot to make the pizza I ordered and they had run out of the pasta I ordered
-
January 2024 by Daniel T. Collier
Amazing pizza and service
-
January 2024 by Samuel Navarro
Irresistible pizzas, perfect crust, and speedy service. A must-try for pizza lovers!
-
January 2024 by Caroline Cassa
You order a "pie" for a hungry family and they hand you 4 small slices and call it a "pie"! Total rip off!