-
October 2023 by JiSup Kim
Amazing lobster rolls (:
-
September 2023 by Marie De
Incredible casual dockside location with accommodating staff, great service and delicious and not overproced food. The only reason for 4 stars for atmosphere is because there was no AC, and it was a very hot day.
-
August 2023 by Maximillian Ward Osborn
Excellent kitchen staff; they get my food exactly how I want it every time. Had dinner from them several times and have never been disappointed. Surprisingly hard to find a good burger in Sag Harbor these days, but from a burger to a lobster roll, they do the simple and crazy crafts perfectly.
-
August 2023 by Jorge D
Small place, few tables for eating inside. Mostly a take out place, very good food. Great lobster bisque. Very good service.
-
August 2023 by Victoria Bayevskiy
Really really good NE clam chowder, especially after a long day of being outside. One bowl ran me about $9.75 +tax. The food came very fast. Very flavorful, and didn’t need any extra spices other than some fresh pepper. It’s tastes exactly like what you think of when you think of New England clam chowder, I would highly recommend.
-
July 2023 by #SmartHomeSecurityNY
Great stop for a bite to go!REALLY liked the way they charr the skin fat on the salmon, however the charr on the burger was overpowering.Would go again ⭐⭐⭐⭐
-
June 2023 by Roxanna Castillo
This hole in the wall seafood spot in Sag Harbor offers delicious lobster rolls, classic, bisque.Take it to go and grab a seat at the picnic tables located across the street on the small little beach.Parking: Be sure you pay and don't allow yourself to expire. During the summer the traffic cops are out in full force.
-
June 2023 by Daniel Antoniazzi
Had lunch here, food was fresh. The lobster roll was good, a little pricey but what isn't in this area? New England clam chowder and lobster bisque were the stars of the show.
-
June 2023 by Roger Merel
Fairly priced classic seafood shack.Both clam chowders were excellent.Steamers were ok although would like be better eaten there.Salad with lobster salad on it was good.Fried shrimp were as expected.Crab cakes were the weakest item we ordered and are mostly bread crumbs and the least desirable crab meat.
-
April 2023 by David Lindskog
I think I've had my best meal ever here. Mostly based on experience but the lobster roll was super.
-
October 2022 by Fabio Gullo
Nice location.Average quality of the food (not the best, not the worst)I ordered the fish tacos and the fish was pretty blend .The chicken sandwich on the other hand was very good.Prices are reasonable for the location.
-
October 2022 by Christopher Magyar
The seafood on display in the refrigerator case looked very fresh. The view of the harbor can only be matched if you had a boat tied up at the dock at Sag Harbor. The clam chowders were good with a slight nod going to the New England preparation. The fried flounder was served on a bun. The portions are generous and the prices are not bad, considering this is the Hamptons. I have one suggestion: abandon the 3.5 per cent surcharge on credit cards and go over to a cash -only policy if the charges that credit -card companies impose are too onerous. One suspects that a seafood shack on the Long Wharf in Sag Harbor does a pretty good business so the surcharge is an annoyance. At least the young man at the counter informed every customer of the surcharge beforehand, although that didn't help me because I wasn't carrying sufficient cash to cover my check.This is a seafood shack, not a formal dining venue like the place next door. They appear to do a good takeout businessParking: It's on the Long Wharf at Sag Harbor so there is obviously no parking in the immediate vicinity. However, I have never had any difficulty finding a parking space nearby, even on a Saturday night.
-
October 2022 by Sydney A.
Quaint spot on Sag Harbors wharf, doesn't look like much from the outside but their food is great! This is a must try for your summer spots as it is now closed for the season. Quality seafood done right, the crab cakes were moist and some of the best I've ever had. The grilled tuna was a generous portion and cooked to perfect temperature. The menu is huge and has something for every seafood lover but if you don't like seafood don't worry they have a burger and even a beyond burger for our non-meat eaters! Check it out and don't forget to grab a South Fork Blondid for dessert.
-
October 2022 by J S.
Best lobster rolls and fresh fish around. Pricing is, what shall I say, the best there is in Sag Harbor. A great place to stop and see people, the water and the yachts
-
September 2022 by James S.
So promising based on the reviews and the big fresh-looking menu, but underwhelming in my experience. Clam chowder - watery and not a ton of flavor. Everyone from miles around has clam chowder and a 'special' recipe. IMO, it's not in evidence here. Not enough clams, and not enough body to the soup. Not sure how they were 'Voted Best'. The scallops sounded good in reviews. When I asked about them at Dock House, they mentioned the fried version, which is battered and fried. It ever there way to hide the flavor of scallops, I'd think that would be it. Instead, the Grilled Marinated Sea Scallops seemed a better fit. I ordered that but was disappointed. The scallops were a bit overcooked, for one thing. The marinade was like spicy brown sauce, sitting on top of the scallops, which themselves sat on a baguette. If you look at the menu online, it mentions the baguette very clearly. For the record, it is listed inside on their big menu, if not as prominently. I never touched the baguette as it struck me as hard to taste the scallops. The waffle fries are good, a bit greasy and have an engaging salty flavor. Was this dish horrible? No. Can I recommend? No. It's a charming place inside. Nice little view of the harbor, if you sit by the window. They're closed a couple days of the week. Would I ever try them again? Sure. But I'm not in a rush.
