Supermarkets near Saint James, NY

472 Lake Avenue, Saint James NY 11780

3.9 Good 144 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 584-8341

“Just wanted to send a special Thank You to Bob in the Deli department. We had a catering order that needed special attention and he was a pleasure to deal with and the food was delicious.”

700 Suffolk Ave, Brentwood NY 11717

4.5 Superb 206 reviews

• Today 7AM – 11PM
• (631) 813-2131

“You will experience kindness generosity respectfully and without doubt the most amazing people you will ever encounter that work in a store. I would go back just for the opportunity to be able to experience what customer service should be. The food flavorful you could smell the spices throughout the store and the quality of the food is nothing like you will taste. I don’t eat meat but I had to pick up dinner for my daughter and she said that I have to go back and get her another plate.”

139 Alexander Avenue, Lake Grove NY 11755

4.3 Superb 173 reviews

• Today 9AM – 8PM
• (855) 955-2534

“It looks like a cleaner store than the others. There is alot all over so I think make a list so you can better navigate around. Some items I got were: avocados, 5 for $3.19 which is good value, Buffalo chicken calzones for $2.79 are hardy and salads in bowls (chicken, lettuce n cheese in separate pockets of the bowl) for $2.59. You can buy a good amount for $40 .”

1070 Islip Ave, Brentwood NY 11717

4.4 Superb 67 reviews

• Today 6AM – 10PM
• (631) 245-6962

“Compare is a family oriented establishment. Fresh produce, bakery and homemade cuisine in food court is a blessing to have available. They have hold community activities and also offer a Tomra recycling machines that are well maintain and ready to accept your products and claim you deposits.”

5147 Sunrise Hwy, Bohemia NY 11716

4.4 Superb 65 reviews

• Today 9AM – 8PM
• (855) 955-2534

“Ulku is the nicest cashier!!! Always has a smile on her face-even after a long day! So courteous & helpful. Store inventory is well-known for being unique with good deals as well as excellent seasonal promotions available. Very good prices...”

318 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

4.2 Good 169 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 580-4720

“Small. So good for quick shopping trip! Veg well stocked. Have look for sales but doable , not like Aldi s prices. I noticed al produce removed at the by time if store closing and area cleaned. No rats noted.”

134 Commack Rd, Commack NY 11725

4.2 Good 138 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 462-0612

“They have good produce and a good deli department, but their meat department is lacking and that their ground beef looks terrible every day they probably re-grind yesterday‘s meat with new meat to try to make it look better and it never works that way.”

42 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore NY 11706

4.3 Superb 74 reviews

• Today 8AM – 9PM
• (631) 242-7068

“I had an excellent experience at Dairy City Supermarket! The customer service was top-notch—everyone was so friendly and helpful. I was in and out quickly, thanks to their fast checkout process. I also grabbed a sandwich while I was there, their buffalo chicken sandwich was absolutely delicious—definitely a 10/10. I'll definitely be coming back.”

821 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

4.1 Good 164 reviews

• Today 6AM – 11PM
• (631) 467-4474

“If I could give them 10 stars, I would! Not only is the food delicious, the staff is top shelf! Always helpful, always kind - a wonderful local deli & small grocery. Highly recommend! A++++++++++++”

4585 Sunrise Hwy, Bohemia NY 11716

4.1 Good 133 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 319-1901

“I love Giuntas cold cuts and baked bread... I like their produce and sometimes the clearance section stuff. Unfortunately, some items are more expensive than the "Big" supermarkets... but depending on what you go there for, you can't find better anywhere else.”

1067 NY-112, Port Jefferson Station NY 11776

4.1 Good 129 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 474-3910

“Good produce is consistant, but prices on other things are higher after covid. You can find items on sale, this along with the produce keeps this market in my rotation.”

29 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point NY 11715

4.1 Good 119 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 363-2593

“Great neighborhood grocery store! The staff is always friendly and helpful. The store itself is clean and neat with a good selection of items. It sure beats having to go up on Sunrise Highway to do my daily shopping. Thanks King Kullen.”

174 Wheeler Road, Central Islip NY 11722

4.1 Good 113 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 851-0576

“If you're looking for Hispanic Culture ingredients, baked goods, or snacks among so much more this is an excellent choice for all sorts of items you won't see in a typical supermarket depending on your area. Of course they carry many standard supermarket items.”

865 Lowell Ave, Central Islip NY 11722

4.6 Superb 18 reviews

• Today 8AM – 7PM
• (631) 439-0460

“We loved the old fashioned more for for your buck treatment. Their meat pkg deals are generous, its enough to last the month. Huge saving compared to supermarkets.”

179 South Ocean Avenue, Patchogue NY 11772

4.1 Good 78 reviews

• Today 8AM – 9PM
• (631) 363-2913

“A beautiful supermarket on south ocean very well stocked good prices and a lot to choose from . As soon as you walk in you smell fresh baked bread fish ? yummy will shop here regularly.”

614 Middle Country Road, Selden NY 11784

4 Good 180 reviews

• Today 9AM – 8PM
• (855) 955-2534

“This is such a great location; the produce I've gotten is always great, not to mention well-priced. The checkout is fast, easy and friendly unlike most markets that keep you waiting forever. I've gotten such cool little knick knacks there too, there are surprisingly cool toys! I found a puzzle brand there that I'm obsessed with now, and they have amazing cookies and chocolates that are hard to find and made good little gifts (plus great for cravings.) I actually enjoy shopping here, it's fun to look at new stuff and a good way to get gift ideas!”

440 Sunrise Hwy, Patchogue NY 11772

4 Good 161 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 569-7809

“I have disabilities and the staff here were so kind and helpful even at the end of the day. They helped me get a mobility cart which on a separate note would be really helpful to have at the front door so don't have to wander in pain looking for them, but staff stepped in and helped. Even at check out I accidentally dropped my phone and someone picked it up for me. The staff told me to ride the car to the car and they even walked out with me put my groceries in the trunk and took the cart back to the building to charge. It was so helpful and kind period A+ on service”

367 Sunrise Highway, Patchogue NY 11772

4 Good 155 reviews

• Today 8:30AM – 8PM
• (855) 955-2534

“I want to specially say thank you to Bryan, he went above and beyond by helping me with the pick order I got every week (I was kind of upset with the service, always got the fruits in bad condition) but he was very helpful and collaborative, definitely fix what his co-workers did wrong! Thank you! And overall the store is goor and organized!”

1105 Horseblock Road, Farmingville NY 11738

4 Good 128 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 880-7770

“Pretty good variety of food and drinks always clean and never disappoints the only concern I have is about the meat every time I buy my meat from here it makes my stomach hurt but it’s still good would recommend coming here”

575 Smithtown Bypass, Hauppauge NY 11788

4 Good 91 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 406-7509

“The gentleman at the meat department are very nice. About 2 weeks ago, I asked about pork loin to make pulled pork and they didn't have much on display. Even though this person was extremely busy, I interrupted him nicely and he made me the most beautiful pork loin. I can't recall if it was 3 lbs but it was under $10!! The one I was going to choose was 5 lb. It had a lot of fat on it and it was $22 and it was lesser quality of pork. I wish I asked for his name. Because I wanted to thank him for his excellent service.”

36 Wheeler Rd, Central Islip NY 11722

4.2 Good 5 reviews

• Today 10AM – 7PM
• (631) 714-4490

1626 Brentwood Rd, Brentwood NY 11717

3.9 Good 91 reviews

• Today 8AM – 7:45PM
• (631) 231-3552

“Nice place to shop, prices are better on many items than big chain supermarkets, while Brand selection is not. Parking lot can be hectic at times especially with the food truck and peddlers selling rugs, lawn statues, shaved ice and cut fruit along the perimeter. People inside are friendly and helpful and the lines if there are any move very quickly. Fresh produce really is a high point here especially for Hispanic or South American cuisine.”

198 main street, Rte 25A, Setauket- East Setauket NY 11733

3.9 Good 101 reviews

• Today 8AM – 9PM
• (631) 246-5500

“Wild by Nature is a wonderful shopping destination for anyone embracing a vegan or vegetarian lifestyle or simply seeking earth-friendly products. The store boasts a wide range of essentials, from natural remedies like essential oils to eco-conscious household items. It’s truly a hub for those who value sustainable living. During my visit, I picked up some paper goods—plates, forks, and knives—along with garbage bags and a small, handmade soap. The atmosphere inside was peaceful, although a bit on the darker side, perhaps to conserve energy, which aligns with the store’s eco-conscious vibe. While the hot food section wasn’t quite as fresh as I’d hoped when I stopped by around 6 p.m., the overall experience was pleasant and calming. That said, it’s worth noting that shopping here isn’t budget-friendly. My small haul came to $68, which caught me by surprise. Next time, I’ll be sure to bring a better-stocked wallet! Still, if you’re looking for unique, natural, and environmentally friendly items, Wild by Nature is worth exploring.”

425 Portion Road, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

3.9 Good 139 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 737-1576

“You get the good with the bad. One days when the place is mobbed there goes an hour of your life waiting on line. But most days I have no complaints, In and Out. Most everything for a kitchen is there.”

40 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack NY 11725

3.9 Good 151 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 499-8350

“Great store great seafood selection prices very fair no self service no check line in store butcher great meats fresh bread cold cuts salids best supermarket on the island”

1851 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore NY 11706

3.9 Good 185 reviews

• Today 8:30AM – 8:30PM
• (855) 955-2534

“My experience was ok. There were only 2 cashiers and the lines were very long. Finally another cashier came on to help get the lines and customers out. The prices have increased, like everywhere else, but Aldi is still the cheapest store to shop at.”

101 Wicks Road, Brentwood NY 11717

3.9 Good 196 reviews

• Today 7AM – 11:30PM
• (631) 236-4696

“The store is organized nice place to shop n you basically find everything u need in one stop to bad there’s only one in the surrounding area and i have to travel from Medford there should be another like it in the Coram area”

1228 Middle Country Rd, Selden NY 11784

3.8 Good 71 reviews

• Today 10AM – 10PM
• (631) 696-2323

“Our condolences to Mr. Nasir & his family from House of Spice. Allah test those who are close to him. May Allah provide you with the patience for such a difficult task! Those who are viewing this post, please make supplication for these two families. God bless you!”

147 Ronkonkoma Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

3.7 Good 29 reviews

• Today 9AM – 8PM
• (855) 955-2534

“Really awesome store, very clean and well organized, great deals and nice staff! Would be good to have more motorized scooters but that is neither here nor there”

379 Horseblock Road, Farmingville NY 11738

3.8 Good 105 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 696-2430

“A great place to do your grocery shopping—good selection and affordable prices. Fresh fruits and vegetables, juicy meat, and excellent fish and seafood; there are definitely plenty of good reasons to shop here. Plus, there’s a senior discount on Wednesdays for extra savings.”