Antiques near Sayville, NY

15 locations found near Sayville

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 30 Railroad Ave, Sayville NY 11782

    5 Superb 16 reviews

    “I purposely went to Sayville so that I could go to 30 Hamptons West. And as expected I was delighted by the experience!The second you walk in the boutique, you feel welcomed and comfortable. Maria greeted me with the warmest smile as I entered. I took my time and looked at every nook and cranny in the store because there are so many amazing finds. I am always shocked at how affordable these finds are. What added to the experience was the opportunity to have a discussion with Maria about art and about choosing just the right items to be in the boutique. Maria has such a bright aura which created such a great dialogue between the two of us. There was an amazing dresser that Maria and her team, restored and painted that I wanted so badly if I only had the available space at home. The price was amazingly reasonable! I asked how she could sell that item for that price and she said when she purchased the dresser (as well as any other items that she either restores or items that are created), she wants to pass the savings back to the consumer. How many shopkeepers do that?! Not often.If you haven’t been to 30 Hamptons West, you have to go. And if you’ve been there before, you need to go back because there are always different and amazing finds every time you go.”

  2. 136 A W Main Street, Sayville NY 11782

    4.4 Superb 28 reviews

    “Phyllis is great! I was worried about having things shipped without being there in person, but everything went really well just as promised. So thank you, Phyllis it’s a pleasure doing business with you and I look forward to much more. She got my items to the UPS store sooner than expected, and I received them promptly.”

  3. 127 Smithtown Boulevard, Nesconset NY 11767

    4.8 Superb 107 reviews

    “I had the absolute best experience at this thrift store! As an inpatient therapist, I was on the hunt for some good books to add to my facility’s collection, and I was completely blown away by the hospitality. The owner and the staff were exceptionally kind, welcoming, and genuinely interested in helping me find what I needed (even offering to take the books out to my vehicle). The owner went above and beyond to assist me, offering incredible recommendations. It is rare to encounter such warmth and community spirit these days! I appreciate him so very much! If you are looking for hidden gems, great reads, or just want to support a business run by wonderful people, this is the place to go. I left with my arms full of wonderful finds and a huge smile on my face. I will definitely be returning!”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 2789 Middle Country Road, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4.7 Superb 122 reviews

    “This has become my absolute favorite antique shop. I stop in regularly, and somehow I always find something interesting that I didn’t know I was looking for. The selection is fantastic and constantly changing, with everything from jewelry and decorative pieces to genuinely unusual finds that are just fun to discover.”

  6. 2394 Middle Country Rd, Centereach NY 11720

    4.8 Superb 80 reviews

    “An absolute gem. Packed floor to ceiling with all manner of treasure and super friendly staff. Definitely will become my go-to for cards when I'm in the area!”

  7. 901 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale NY 11769

    4.6 Superb 168 reviews

    “My mom and I love coming to this shop! There are so many interesting and unique pieces. We’ve spent hours there just looking through the different items, and are always finding something neat! Some are decently priced while others seem higher in comparison to similar pieces from other vintage shops.”

  8. 1236 Montauk Highway, Oakdale NY 11769

    4.8 Superb 68 reviews

    “I finally made the drive to see what this place was all about. It had about every antique category you can think of and a ton of watches. Kirk was patient with answering my questions. Highly recommend. Thanks Kirk I will be back.”

  9. 283 Portion Road, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    4.7 Superb 48 reviews

    “Yesterday we visited Ronkonkoma Rare Coins & Books to sell some old gold and silver jewelry, and we had a great experience. Theo, the owner, was extremely friendly and took the time to walk us through the process, which made us feel very comfortable. We had done some research beforehand, and based on that, we felt the offer we received was very fair. It was clear that Theo is honest and knowledgeable, which made the whole transaction smooth and stress-free. We would definitely go back and highly recommend Ronkonkoma Rare Coins & Books to anyone looking to sell jewelry or coins in a trustworthy and welcoming environment.”

  10. 425 N Country Rd, St James NY 11780

    4.5 Superb 59 reviews

    “This place is so cool. I think it's the best antique shop on the island. Not that I've been to every, but it had so many items I've not seen before. Stuff from all the way back in the 1930s. Beautiful pieces from silk scarves to a fire extinguisher. Also the staff was SOOO nice! And funny. Will definitely be back”

  11. 2860 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4.4 Superb 64 reviews

    “This place seems to have some pretty good stuff in comparison to other antique/collectible store. The only thing that I find odd is the store is reselling an unusual amount of new wave transformers for 50% MSRP. While there is a Target and Walmart nearby.”

  12. 1525 Ocean Ave, Bohemia NY 11716

    4.8 Superb 12 reviews

    “So happy I found Eagle Brass to polish up some aluminum trim parts from my Chevelle. Pete is such a nice guy and he did a fantastic job, his communication with me was on point.”

  13. 380 Central Avenue # B, Bohemia NY 11716

    5 Superb 9 reviews

    “If you have a Model A, Bob is a wealth of information. He is my go to guy for parts, service and is very knowledgeable. If you don't have a Model A get one.”

  14. 1675 Roosevelt Ave B, Bohemia NY 11716

    5 Superb 5 reviews

    “Thank you so very Much to Alex and The Wonderful Staff at Luis RestorationKind , Polite , Professional and Most Helpful . I am in the process of Restoring a Antique Radio There are a few brass Pieces that needed to be Refinished . So happy I made the Right call as I reached Out to Luis . The Work is Outstanding and at a Very Fair Price5 Stars Highly Recommend”

  15. 152 South Country Road, Bellport NY 11713

    3.7 Good 16 reviews

    “Cornell Auctions is the BEST auction house not just on Long Island, but in the whole world! They have the best antiques, collectibles, and are super friendly and helpful. They truly care about their customers and I really enjoy working with them and bidding on cool items! I won a lot of cool Shakespeare books from them! They really treat you like family and I highly recommend taking a look at the cool items they have and bid in their auctions! Happy Holidays!”

  16. 36 Ocean Avenue, Islip NY 11751

    3 Average 4 reviews

    “Took the time to explain all our options regarding our Moms Estate. Very knowledgeable, professional and caring team. Was very pleased how they ran the sale and the amount of money that was generated. I highly recommend them!”

Advertisement

Antiques in nearby cities