-
March 2024 by Steve C.
Decent place but overall not too crazy about it. The Ceasar salad I had absolutely went right through me. Not sure what it was that did it to me. My mother in law had a chicken and broccoli dish that I tried and it tasted amazing. I will go that route next time for sure.
-
January 2024 by Kevin Horton
Got the stuffed meat Sicilian. Delicious- filling.
-
December 2023 by Howie K
Great salads & wonderful creamy dressing. Get an extra one on the side! Rich robust vodka sauce for a pasta dish.
-
December 2023 by Michael Nathan
Average
-
December 2023 by Single S.
Me and my wife have been customers for 2 years! What we love about this place is how consistent they are. There's no worrying about getting a great pizza one day and then a meh one the next -- they're always good! Plus, the staff is very friendly and their service is great. We can't recommend them enough! 10/10
-
November 2023 by Jennifer N.
A good slice or pie if you like a crispy bottom crust. Everywhere else I would have to order "well done" to get what is consistently served here. Never greasy.
-
October 2023 by Terence Goff
My favorite pizza in town! The dough is a bit thick so you have to like that. The owners are very personable and the place is always clean.
-
October 2023 by Darlyn D.
Food is amazing. Great specials. Efficient cordial staff. Eat in or take out it's the best!!
-
October 2023 by Joseph L.
I regularly order a variety of pizza and dinner dishes to pick up from Pezzi and they are always delicious, well-prepared, ready when they promise and the staff is attentive and efficient. Calogero always greets me and all guests with a smile and makes sure that the order is correct. I highly recommend Pezzi for all types of italian food!
-
September 2023 by Kenney H.
The food is amazing the service is great the best pizza on the north shore of Long Island
-
September 2023 by David C
That’s the Buffalo chicken I ordered, the worst I ever had. Tiny bit size chicken, no flavor. That’s totally a joke.
-
August 2023 by Christopher Williams
Absolutely love their pizza and garlic knots. It reminds of an old fashion pizza place. Very polite staff and lovely food and drinks.
-
June 2023 by markwilliamsheehan
Kindly clone, "Calogero" who meets & greets us all on arrival. He's been on the site for over 20 years & counting! Thing is, his place was suggested by another Italian Eatery ~ which I'll happily review later... When I asked for the best slice of pizza within 10 miles, 'Dylan' who owns the fine-dining Italian near the Sea Cliff station said... 'Go to Pezzi!' He was right! Fabulous Pizza...and while I was there, I thought I'd also sample the eggplant parm and the homemade spaghetti sauces! Thankfully, they provided 'take away containers! Great place, nice, clean, well-lighted space! Oddly enough, when I've asked other 'locals' for the top spot for a slice...THIS place keeps popping-up! Well done! You're famous locally! I shall be back!
-
June 2023 by robert moffitt
Excellent as always. Great familiar atmosphere ? whether dining in or running out.
-
April 2023 by Peter Bennett
Just as good as it was when I was in high school next door.
