Gift Shops near Selden, NY

24 locations found near Selden

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 347 Independence Plaza, Selden NY 11784

    3 Average 21 reviews

    “The new owner is so nice. I always choose the same place to play my lotto & scratch offs. This is my new place. Remodel looks fantastic. New fun stock. I always pop in here first before my bagel, pizza or Chinese stop. I recommend this location to everyone shopping or eating looking for a quick greeting card/lottery purchase and much more.”

  2. 35 Chandler Square, Port Jefferson NY 11777

    5 Superb 62 reviews

    “this is a cute store. i ended up get a nail/pumis brush, and a soap bar. they have so much to choose from. i thought it was just a refillery but they have clothing, home decor, accessories and more. very nice staff as well.”

  3. 85 Air Park Drive Unit 2, Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    5 Superb 66 reviews

    “This company!!! My daughter has thoroughly enjoyed each item! Not to mention their customer service is honestly above and beyond!! I'm happy to support this company!”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 134 Main Street, Port Jefferson NY 11777

    4.6 Superb 46 reviews

    “Never thought about leaving this place a review till now, but I can't wait to return (Only visit LI once a year, grew up in Valley Stream, but I live in NV) next year because I should've bought more stickers to decorate my vehicle (Thought I bought enough but it turns out I did not) and I do need more. They sell awesome strong waterproof stickers and they stick and stay on your vehicle (Even through heavy rain showers and whenever you go to a car wash) unlike ones I've bought online and very few sellers on eBay sell the same brand of stickers they do. Highly recommend their stickers located in their revolving rack if your looking into decorating your vehicle with stickers without worrying about them getting ruined or peeling off cause they are indeed WATERPROOF AND STRONG.”

  6. 600 Portion Road, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    5 Superb 20 reviews

    “Excellent place to get your gifts. Very friendly people who work there . One stop shop . Please support local businesses. . Highly recommended this place 🧿❤❤”

  7. 5507 Nesconset Hwy # 12A, Mt Sinai NY 11766

    4.5 Superb 46 reviews

    “This place was my 1st experience with buying wacky tabaki LEGALLY (?). The gentleman who helped me was pretty awesome. Super kind and knowledgeable. DIDN'T try to get me to buy more expensive items. Was so genuine. Loved it.”

  8. 813 Montauk Hwy B, Bayport NY 11705

    5 Superb 10 reviews

    “This little store has a rainbow of beautiful stained glass creations hand made by artists Sandy and her daughter Kathy. Pick a beautifully crafted sun catcher, a piece of unique jewely, or a nightlight, or go big with a stained glass bowl or wall hanging. Sandy and Kathy will even etch a message with a name if you'd like. I love my choice: a map of Long Island on glass made with tiny glass fragments and etched with an anchor and "Long Island "”

  9. 146 S Country Rd, Bellport NY 11713

    5 Superb 8 reviews

    “Found this gem on social media and had to stop in myself. Located in the quaint and walkable Bellport village, this spot is a great place to peruse for new items for the home and even some women's clothing as well. I love that it's not decked out in only Rae Dunn and Mud Pie gifts like so many shops these days. Download the app and you can get a preview of what's new in the store.”

  10. 1582 NY-112, Medford NY 11763

    4.5 Superb 19 reviews

    “They have a great selection of one piece and pokemon cards and merch,they have a wide selection of cards ranging in price and a cool selection of anime merch from one piece.They also have some super cool custom binders that were hand made.They also have the newest pokemon set in packs!”

  11. 1844 NY-112 # O, Coram NY 11727

    4.6 Superb 13 reviews

    “It's a nice store there is plenty of room to move freely. I stop in and get a few scratchers from time to time I got a 20 dollar scratch and one 200 last week ?good times”

  12. 600 Portion Rd #12, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    4.8 Superb 6 reviews

    • Today 9AM – 5PM

    “Really well laid out place. I always find a nice little gift there while picking out a card, too. Staff is always nice and helpful to their customers. I witnessed them helping out an older couple, and they couldn't have been more patient and sweet while doing so”

  13. Smith Haven Plaza, 2075 Nesconset Highway, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4.2 Good 50 reviews

    “Too many fabulous buys to describe. Many gift and hostess type items. Seasonal items aplenty. Clothing, jewelry, games, wrapped snacks. Be forewarned: prices are not cheap. Vast greeting card selection. Humorous and x-rated sock selection. Helpful staff.”

  14. 4554 Sunrise Highway, Oakdale NY 11769

    5 Superb 3 reviews

    “It's your standard card shop, but the store is a little larger than his typical. Things are very well spaced out and merchandised. The one thing you need of course is all the way in the back of the store, gift cards and a gift bag. But they were well stocked and moderately priced. Matter of fact they charged me less than the price on the bag. I think it was under $2 and the bag said $3.75. I was able to get in and out with a handful of pokémon cards for somebody's birthday in less than 5 minutes.”

  15. 313 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4 Good 21 reviews

    “ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!! I dealt with Alex from Lake Grove and he was incredible. So helpful and very sincerely involved with the customization and making sure you are happy with your choice. He helped me choose the right size crystal and made some adjustments to make sure it looked perfect. This was a birthday gift for my mom and he was determined to make sure it was great!! He made the 3D look amazing when I was nervous about the photo and was very passionate about what he was doing. Amazing service and so quick, only 3 days max!! Highly recommend and will definitely visit again!!”

  16. 230 East Main Street, Port Jefferson NY 11777

    3.9 Good 47 reviews

    “this store was very cool! they have crystals, sage, and alot of witchy type stuff. i saw these cute scissors that you can use to cut threads or something small. very nice for 20 bucks. i bought the rose gold ones. very nice staff too.”

  17. 250 East Main Street, Port Jefferson NY 11777

    3.9 Good 176 reviews

    “i got a big coconut bar of soap and i love it! its this french brand but i forgot the name. i've purchased this soap before from lother shops and i just love the smell. very cute shop. friendly service too.”

  18. 313 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove NY 11755

    3.8 Good 65 reviews

    “Sooner or later people are going to realize you can't just order everything online you need to touch feel smell and see what a great tragedy it will be if we lose all of our walls I love coming here when I can it's always clean they always have what you need and what you want I hope and pray you never leave thanks for always being there.”

  19. 2140 Middle Country Rd, Centereach NY 11720

    3.4 Good 17 reviews

    “This place is perfect to run in and get cards and gift supplies. They have some really nice giftables here too... And I always grab some scratch offs for my cards too.”

  20. 3251 Horseblock Road, Medford NY 11763

    3.6 Good 113 reviews

    “There was an issue with an arrangement that I had recently sent to a friend. Ultimately, the order needed to be redelivered. Farooq (who is the person that I dealt with at the Horseblock Rd, Medford store) was amazing!! He understood the issue at hand and how much it meant to me to fix the problem. He did everything he could to make sure that issue was addressed and resolved without any inconvenience to me or the recipient. He even delivered the new arrangement, ON HIS OWN TIME, after he left the store for the night, and that kind of work ethic and pride in one’s job performance is so rare…he should be commended for his efforts. I truly appreciate his kindness. The Medford, NY, Edible Arrangement Store is lucky to have an employee like Farooq, who is not only thoughtful, but who’s also so ready and willing to go above and beyond just to make sure that the customer is happy and satisfied with their purchase. Employees are the physical representation of a company…I really hope that Edible Arrangements appreciates the stellar representation provided by Farooq and his commitment to delivering exemplary customer service.”

  21. 601 Portion Road, Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779

    3 Average 63 reviews

    “Hands down the nicest staff! I always order from here for local pick up or deliveries they have the freshest fruit and cleanest store location I’ve experienced. Highly recommend this location!”

  22. 2194D Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook NY 11790

    3.1 Average 101 reviews

    “This delivery of our large Bouquet of fruit, arrived on time, fresh, as presented. Bill the delivery driver, demonstrated his care, by informing me that no one was answering the door. He realized someone was home and waited 10 minutes to complete the delivery. The receiver was overwhelmed and so happy for the delivery. Thank You,”

  23. 346 NY-25A Ste 88, Rocky Point NY 11778

    2.9 Average 79 reviews

    “I can’t say enough good things about them. I have used them multiple times their service is alway kind and fast To me that speaks Remarkable customer service!! I will definitely be returning and keep using them!!Ordered a get well soon arrangement and a chocolate dipped box. This location was fantastic! My order was placed and made the same day, and it looked amazing! The man helping me was so kind and personalized my gift to the recipient which I loved! I thought that was very nice of him to take the time to do that! Delicious treats and such a positive experience. 10/10 recommend this location!”

  24. 911 Montauk Highway, Bayport NY 11705

    2.9 Average 143 reviews

    “I had a minor issue with my original order due to miscommunication. Upon contacting the store, they immediately and without hesitation sent a delivery that exceeded my expectations. It looked better than the picture on the EA website! I am very pleased and I highly recommend this specific store for all occasions! Thank you for making a special moment, extra memorable!”

  25. 25 Mill Creek Road, Port Jefferson NY 11777

    2.3 Poor 58 reviews

    “This was the last gift shop I stopped at on my tour of Port Jefferson on May 2. They had by far the most unique items out of the other gift shops in the area. I got a cool shark shaped mat for my room and a sculpture of an octopus for my shelf. The female owner was very kind in answering my questions about her cute little store. They’ve been open for many years and they have things you won’t find anywhere else.”

Advertisement

Gift Shops in nearby cities