Liquor Stores in Setauket- East Setauket, NY

“Hamlet Wines & Liquors is an outstanding local spot, and the owner is the reason it stands out from the rest! Whether you’re a wine enthusiast or just looking for the perfect bottle for a special occasion, you’ll always leave here feeling confident in your choice.

The owner is incredibly personable and deeply knowledgeable. He takes the time to understand your tastes and consistently offers fantastic recommendations, whether it’s a unique wine, a smooth whiskey, or a spirit you’ve never tried before. I was so excited to score a bottle of Pappy Van Winkle for my boyfriend here!! His passion for his craft is evident in every conversation and suggestion.

The shop itself is well-stocked and inviting, with a wide selection to suit any preference or budget. It’s the kind of place where you can browse comfortably or rely on expert guidance to discover something special.

If you’re looking for excellent service and high-quality products, Hamlet Wines & Liquors is the place to go. The owner’s expertise and dedication make it a standout in the community. Highly recommend! ??”

“I ordered a case of a specific port wine to be delivered to a friend in Maryland. The service I received could not have been better. I highly recommend this store.”

“Great selection and great staff. Whether you want good bourbon, low calorie wine, sake, or the single serve Beatbox cartons they keep in the fridge for when you feel like a bum, they have it all.”

“Stopped in on Friday night after a hiatus from this store because previous ownership had old stock and made up prices. WOW, what a difference the new owners have made!! Store was well stocked and reasonably priced. Congratulations to the new owners!!”

“This place is back to being my go to liquor store! Several years ago I started going somewhere else because it started going down hill (rude staff, not helpful, didn't seem like they were keeping up with appearance, etc.) , but I recently remembered this place is under new ownership the last few years, and I really like the location of the store, so I started going back again to give it another try. What a difference! The store is very clean and it's easy to find what you're looking for. The staff are always friendly and helpful! They offer good recommendations when you need them, but also know how to leave you alone when you're just browsing. A lot of people I know say they have good sales too. Personally I don't often pay attention to them because I usually already know what I want. There is a decent wine selection and the prices for everything are very fair.”