-
October 2023 by Daniel LiCalzi
Please hire more pleasant staff.
-
October 2023 by Garry Cooper
Bedbugs!
-
September 2023 by mehmet pala
Amazing place i feel like i am in Europe, super cool sandy beach and tasty food and friday nights all full. ?????
-
September 2023 by Destiny Pomarico
The food was ok, the waiter was nice but it’s mainly for the view.
-
September 2023 by Luke Pardue
Terrible vibes. Hostesses seat their friends instead of your reservation. Bartenders suck.
-
September 2023 by David C
Lol $400 a night, they got to be joking, looks like a dumpy motel.
-
September 2023 by Martyna McClendon
Drinks & vibe were great but the food was awful.
-
August 2023 by Pamela M.
Not worth the hype. Got a glass at the bar & when seated at the table, they forgot my 2nd glass of rosé. Everyone else got their drink. I asked 3x!!!! Seriously. Then gave me a small pour compared to others at my table. My Niçoise salad was tuna from a can. It took 30 extra min to get orders without any explanation at the beginning. Do not recommend.
-
August 2023 by Heather Dolland Tamam
We've been to Sunset Beach many times over the years. But this is the first time we stayed at the hotel.Amazingly bright and spacious rooms with balconies.Great place to enjoy good drinks, food and just relax.Definitely the most vibes on Shelter Island.
-
August 2023 by 312hopeb
The beautiful location makes Shelter Island one of our favorite spots to get away from city life. That being said, I can’t recommend this overpriced, pretentious hotel. We had to ask every day to get someone to clean our room and then call again - and again - to get new glasses or towels. They forgot to bring our breakfast and charged ridiculous prices for mediocre fare in the restaurant. Avoid this place and enjoy the beauty of the island instead.
-
August 2023 by Al
Awful service at the bar on the 4th of July!Thank you for ruining the experience for me!
-
August 2023 by Anna Huyghues Despointes
I had to cancel a reservation because of a medical emergency, I called them. I was told everything was taken care off, then I was charged $200 for no-show. It's been months and I have called multiple times, every time they say it will get reimbursed and then nothing happens. It is such a low level of service.
-
July 2023 by Kalene E.
This place is beautiful but the service is awful. Come get a drink at the bar, do not eat here. We sat down at 8 and ordered pretty quickly, all the cold dishes came out fast but for a full hour no one checked on us. No one came to take drink orders, tell us where our food was, and water cups sat empty. I wouldn't mind waiting if drinks were flowing but there was no contact for a full hour. There were other larger groups getting antsy as well (and getting into it with the waiter I might add). If it was like this on a Wednesday I can't imagine the wait/service when it is actually busy. Shoutout to the back waiters and bussers that were hustling as the waiters were nowhere in sight.
-
July 2023 by Sergio Biagiotti
Had a reservation @ 3.30pm but hostess said kitchen closes @ 3.30pm so technically impossível to order lunch with this reservation. Arriving at 3.40 we were denied a table in an ironic way.Hostess/staff were rude to us. Unfortunately not worth it anymore, sunset beach is not the friendly/nice place it was a few years back.
-
July 2023 by Owen Hayes
Sunset Beach is a Shelter Island institution. Always a great time. French fries and frosé are a hit, beach scenery is lovely, and the music is top notch.
