Black Cat Books is a charming and well-organized used bookstore located in Shelter Island. It offers a diverse selection of books, including first edition collector items, modern fiction, and an emphasis on art and photography. The shop is clean and features categories that are often missing in larger retailers, making it a must-visit for book lovers. With a lovely owner and a welcoming atmosphere, Black Cat Books is a delightful stop for anyone interested in exploring a variety of literary topics.
Absolutely lovely book store with a surprising mix of classics and moderns all for excellent prices. I typically go to shelter island for the trails but this book store is almost reason enough on its own. I think they could potentially benefit from having a bit more seating area for customers but otherwise really great... read full comment
October 2025
Absolutely loved visiting this place! Amazing selection and amazing prices. The person who helped us check out was so conversational and had a story about nearly every book I bought. Would love to go back just to visit and hear more!
October 2025
The music taste is elite. The book and art selections are pretty cool too.
