-
December 2023 by Robin Conyers
Delicious food. The best on the island. Everyone is very friendly.I can’t wait to come back
-
December 2023 by Mary Vella
Delicious ?
-
November 2023 by Monica Liva
Absolutely love this place!
-
October 2023 by Bennett Karnis
The Food , The Music , Commander Cody andChef Amanda and their entire staff...are professional courteous and fun... That gets the job done...?❤️???⛳?
-
October 2023 by jeffrey tucker
The fish was fresh. The service was outstanding
-
October 2023 by Penelope Moore
Commander Cody’s Fish Market is a mainstay on Shelter Island. Owners Jimmy Hayward and his daughter Amanda, serve the best fried chicken and assortment of smoked fish that people come from far and wide to enjoy. Recently I stopped in and got containers of prepared food from their fridge: potato salad cole slaw, ribs (to warm up at home) and smoked bluefish, and it was absolutely delicious. The smoked ribs are to die for, by the way. With family-run restaurants with a personal touch becoming such a rarity in this area, we are fortunate to have Commander Cody’s here on our little island. During peak times in the summer, the parking can get a little tight so parking on the street is a good idea. Following a Hamptons magazine review, Commander Cody’s got “discovered” and during the summer it is often best to order hot food in advance. As is often the case for the best, there might be a wait, but the outcome is worth it.
-
October 2023 by moses burdon
apparently the food is good but a three hour wait to get served is unacceptable. congratulations your business is growing. unfortunately you're not growing with it. there's no excuse for 3 hour wait for fried fish. No excuse
-
September 2023 by Jennifer Martinelli
Stopped by to have lunch on a Saturday afternoon after reading such good reviews. The lady behind the counter was extremely rude and complaining that we couldn't order food because she was just way too busy to cook. She turned so much business away and many like myself said we will never return. The young man who ran the counter was so embarrassed and apologized. Save yourself a trip because its not worth getting yelled at for trying to give them business. Why have a restaurant??
-
September 2023 by The Palmfather
This is a cornerstone of the Shelter Island community and I have eaten here since I was in grade school on the island. It is a mix of the best seafood the area has to offer as well as some great soul food mixed in. It has a very homey setting and is not pretentious like many restaurants in the area. This is a must visit for anyone vacationing on the island, the residents already know this!
-
September 2023 by James R.
Fried chicken, ribs, cole slaw, outstanding, order early in day for 6 pm pickup, 30 pc. Fed 12 no problem
-
August 2023 by Je Ni
Love Commander Cody's! We've been eating there for years and never had a bad meal. Everything is FRESH and cooked on the spot.
-
July 2023 by Douglas Ennis
Great atmosphere excellent food, but over priced
-
July 2023 by Terence Fox
Very authentic cuisine that doesn’t break the bank. Absolutely love this place and I hope to return soon. Very fresh options.
-
July 2023 by Irene Valliant
Food was good. It is a bait and switch. We were told this was a scam website. Receipt had a different restaurant name on it.
-
July 2023 by Cassandra Leggio (Cassandra)
Amazing Staff! Shout out to Aiden! The hook-up is fire! Craving a tasty, delectable, fresh catch- this is the spot to go! Love the vibe here as well. Perfect for the perfect way to start the summer season that you'll crave year round. The patio lends itself to whatever suits your style.
