Gift Shops near Shelter Island, NY

4 locations found near Shelter Island

“looks like a great place. When I was living in Avalon New Jersey, we had a same named gift shop. Many nice memories a family members buying gifts to take back home on vacation time was over for them. Of course we lived on the island you around they all guess that we were getting were when we won tickets at ski ball and could buy a little gifts for my grandmother”

5 Superb16 Reviews

“Wow this place is just incredible. I got their face scrub, olive oil soap, shampoo bar, and face serum. The owner even allowed me to get a smaller bottle of their scalp serum which has my hair looking so healthy after just once use! My skin and body has never felt more refreshed. So happy I found this little place :) The owners are so sweet and you can tell they’re genuine, pleasant people. The face scrub is sooo delightful, my skin felt so so soft. I also got some sage with pretty pink flowers. They also have such a thoughtfully curated selection of homeware. 10/10 ?”

5 Superb32 Reviews

“Mel helped us create the most beautiful wedding invitations! She guided us through every step of the process, giving helpful suggestions. I am usually pretty indecisive, but Mel made it simple and fun. This wound up being one of my favorite parts of wedding planning! Coming in without a specific “vision” Mel was able to help us create something very special and reflective of our day. I am so grateful for her creative advice and patience!”

4.9 Superb11 Reviews

““I love shopping here! The store always has such a cute selection of North Fork apparel. Perfect place to grab a gift or something to remember your trip out to Greenport. The staff is friendly and helpful without being pushy, which makes the experience even better. And they are local owners which I always love to support local businesses! The quality of the clothes is excellent and I always find something I love. Highly recommend!””

4.9 Superb30 Reviews