Gift Shops near Shelter Island, NY
5 locations found near Shelter Island
View Map
Gift Shops
Gift Shops
“What an incredible shop! If my mind was store this would be it! The selection, quality kitchen items and cute entertaining pieces were all a must have. I didn’t see a single thing I didn’t want! If you need a gift, this is the place for something they will surely love and not already have. Can’t wait to visit again and stock up.”
Gift Shops
“The best North Fork gear in town! If you don’t have a sweatshirt from them get one! We have some from several years ago that still look like new and are the absolute softest. Top quality and the owners are so helpful & kind!”
Gift Shops
“Melinda at Arni Paperie did an incredible job on everything for our daughter’s wedding. She was knowledgeable, organized, and patient. From the invitation, which set just the right tone for the entire evening, to all the day-of items, she worked with us to customize everything until it was just right and delivered it all without a single glitch. Her store also has a wonderful selection of gifts for any occasion. Thank you, Melinda!”
11AM - 4PM
123 Main St, Greenport
Gift Shops
“Excellent and friendly customer service and a wonderful collection of gifts and knickknacks.Also, every so often tucked out of sight on a corner shelf you might discover a novel or two like lord of the rings or another fantasy novel for beach reading ?”