-
November 2023 by Thomas Oliva
A hidden gem
-
September 2023 by John Hoppe
Have been here multiple times over the years. The crew is friendly and helpful and the Salt restaurant and bar get better and better.
-
July 2023 by Robert Corrado
I’ve been to Island Boatyard several times, and I must say my wife and I always enjoy going there. I find the staff very nice but also very young. They are helpful, but I like to tie up my own boat as well as connect electric but they are there to help if needed having the restaurant right there an outdoor bar, a pool, the water a beach has basically everything you need for a great boating vacation spot. if anyone from Island Boatyard, his reading this I have two small requests. As a transient is there anyway we can get better Internet service in the Marina area. The last several times that I’ve been there there’s always been very weak Internet service also a garbage pail near the dock, would be nice as well as it’s a long walk to the dumpster and sometimes difficult to open, you have the staff there? I’m sure it should not be a problem thank you.
-
August 2022 by Stephen Rolka
Megan, Liam, Ellie, Riley were great. Wonderful time! We will be back!
-
August 2022 by Ben Monge
(Translated by Google) A dream place! Too cute! And excellent care!(Original)Un lugar de ensueño! Demasiado lindo! Y una atención excelente!!
-
November 2021 by Brooke Tortorella
Beyond thankful to have booked the Boathouse for our wedding.First off, the location is one of the most picturesque spots I have seen. If you love nature and the water but want the option for an indoor/outdoor wedding, the Boathouse is the perfect option. Second, James and Megan were extremely helpful and ensured the day went smooth. Leading up to the day, Megan was so helpful and responsible. I had a number of logistical questions and Megan really went above and beyond and she always responded to my email in less than 24 hours! She is the down to earth, knowledgeable, and I really felt she went above and beyond to ensure everything went smoothly. Finally, if you want to include your personal flair into your wedding, the Boathouse will make your dreams come true. All of our guests are still talking about how beautiful the space was. There are so many great options for pictures before dinner, including a beautiful sunset. Book your wedding at the Boathouse ASAP!
-
September 2021 by Harry Gates (Captain)
Outstanding in every way. One of the best!
-
August 2021 by Harry Gates
Outstanding in every way. One of the best!
-
August 2020 by Richard Augustine
Love it great place and staff
-
July 2020 by Robert Lyman
They should have told us the pool was not In Use this year.... Huge issue on 90plus weekend
-
October 2019 by Robert Geehreng
I wouldn't keep my yacht anyplace but the IBM on Shelter Island
-
August 2019 by John H.
Been going here for a few years now. I don't understand the negative reviews because we've always had good experiences with transient docking. The facilities are immaculately maintained and the food is great. We've yet to eat at the restaurant (Salt) because it's always booked, but they bring food to the outside bar area. The staff seem friendly and accommodating. Enjoy the experience every time.
-
August 2019 by Steven Futoran
Overall awesome place..marina is beautiful with great service.
-
July 2018 by Charles C.
I purchased a sailboat from boat angel about 8 months ago and the boat had been abandon by its previous owner at this boatyard on a sleepy little town on the tip of long island. This boat yard is about a 5 hour drive away form where I live. In January I called the boat yard and scheduled out an appointment with them to see the boat and begin cleaning it up. i ensured they had my address and contact information and told them to invoice me as needed. The gentlemen i spoke with appeared to be some kind of manager but I'm not totally sure. the winter came and went so, (about 4 months) before I was able to come back out to the boatyard to do more preparation on it. I had not received any invoices for services or storage so i told the same gentleman (Wade) that i had not received anything in the form of a bill. in a nonchalant tone Wade remarked " that's just because we haven't invoiced you" He was friendly and made small talk through out seeing him on this day. I had been out to see the boat two more times for preparatory work and did not see Wade, though I tried knocking on his door. I had also called and left messages 3 times between January and July to get the vessel serviced. I had paid $800 for the vessel and $200 for vessel storage fees for January. So, in July; I speak with a manager at Boat Angel (Brian Stewart) he says that he spoke with the boat yard. He said that I need to pay my bills there and he told me that the boatyard told him that I have not paid since January and that he was told by the boatyard that I had abandon it. I told him about my recent trip there for preparation and how... Brian interrupted me saying "just pay your bill" "i didn't ask when you went there". I was becoming frustrated He accused me of not paying my bill and abandoning the boat I bought from the charity he represented (Boat Angel). Any time I tried to defend my position, Brian raised his voice and interrupted me saying "PAY YOUR BILL" or "I DIDNT ASK YOU THAT" I was astounded that the boat yard told him that I had not paid my bill and abandon the boat, since I had made so many attempts to get it in the water and out of the boat yard. I was even more astounded that this man Brian Stewart yelled at me , interrupted me and treated me so disrespectfully. Now that my boat is in the water and I no longer have to deal with either of these men. i will never do business with Boat Angel or the Shelter Island NY Boat Yard again.
-
January 2018 by E B.
I've had a slip here since 2003 and I couldn't be happier. The staff is friendly and accommodating. I have had some significant repairs done here with zero issues.
