-
March 2024 by Ben Morse
One of the last few places both tourists and locals can get a reasonably priced meal. Have been coming to stars cafe since It opened. Stay reasonably priced stars.
-
February 2024 by Anthony Muljadi
Great place to get a quick bite or a full meal! Delicious and diverse
-
December 2023 by Teresa Mansilla
I love
-
November 2023 by Stacey H.
wonderful cafe with delicious breakfast. coffee was really good. the food was great. a friend in our party isn't able to have gluten and they had a delicious gluten free french toast. highly recommend.
-
October 2023 by Jeff Crystal
It was hot inside and very crowded. Breakfast food was great.
-
September 2023 by 286karene
Bought their zucchini bread which was outstanding and my husband had their Nutella filled donuts. Very kind people. Delicious food and they know their products very well. Visit them in the store or at havens market on Saturday !
-
August 2023 by Dean Ronzoni
Good little coffee shop on the north side. Went twice while I was in town. Second time there they said they have a policy of no computers. Strange to me cuz they do have free internet. Oh well I guess it’s not a good place to work for an hour or have meetings where you need a computer to look at.
-
July 2023 by Sam Gill
Rude The whole staff looked like they did not want me to be there and asked if I was getting my food to go . I definitely did NOT feel welcome. 2nd trip there and both times same vibe. Won’t get my money again. Soda Fountain on corner was very pleasant and knows what customer service is. Burgers not as fancy but simple is sometimes better when you feel welcome.A girl holding the broom asked “how can I help you ?” When I walked in. I was the only costumer. How is a girl holding a broom going to help me? I need one at the cash register to help me. Of course I came here to order food . What’s the girl with a broom going to do for me? Sweep me a path to the register? And whit would you ask if you could help me do that? If you want to do something for me with that broom then Show me what you can do with that broom. I have no idea what tricks you may possessThe server did bring the food out politely and I do want to say she was the only one smilingWe went to the Marie French place on the water a few days later. (It was closed when we sent to stars). The line was long and people waited for the food and service. All employees smiling and happy to be at work. Stars needs to take notes. You want customers out the door? Wear a smile. Make people like you. Monkey see monkey do. “What are those guys doing different than we are” is what you need to be asking yourself. If you cared to grow your business you would try. What i experienced was no one there cares if you turn around and walk out or if you stay and eat. And the line to the register shows that I am not the only one that feels this way.
-
July 2023 by Neky Romero
Great cafe in Shelter Island. The food was great went back everyday this weekend and the staff was so friendly. Highly recommend.
-
June 2023 by Sarah Hayes
Small business or not there are standards that all businesses should uphold.First is customer service. The cashier was not welcoming at all. No smile even when I tried to make a joke to lighten up the mood. You are the face for the business. You are the person who makes the first impression for new comers like me. Remember that.The food portions were decent for the price but the food was so bland. I’m not sure if they used salt at all.I will not be returning.
-
June 2023 by justin kaplan
Stars Cafe: Brace yourself for the epitome of cinnamon roll perfection. From the first heavenly bite, you'll be enchanted by its pillowy softness and the harmonious blend of sweet cinnamon and sugar. The flavors dance on your palate, leaving you craving more. The delicate balance between the indulgent filling and the tender dough is a stroke of genius. Topped with a velvety cream cheese icing that adds the perfect tangy touch, it's a symphony of taste and texture. Stars Cafe has truly mastered the art of crafting cinnamon rolls that redefine decadence. You'll find yourself transported to a realm of pure bliss with each and every bite. This is an unforgettable cinnamon roll experience that you simply cannot miss.
-
May 2023 by Max B
So nice to have a reliably solid place like this on the island. Lots of menu options and often very busy due to the limited options on Shelter but the staff is always friendly and working hard.
-
April 2023 by Joseph Messing
Fabulous sweet treats, coffee, as well as salads and sandwiches. Toasted corn muffins and coffee are a match made in heaven.
-
March 2023 by Donna P.
We LOVE everything about Stars! Coffee to start the day is the best anywhere. Pastries, breakfast burritos and sandwiches @lunch always good! And hamburgers on Thurs. Burger Night, are amazing. Special order a Birthday cake and you'll thank me!
-
January 2023 by Brett Kelly
Nice place in Shelter Island Heights for early risers to pick up some light breakfast of homemade baked goods and great coffee.
