Supermarkets near Shelter Island, NY

6 locations found near Shelter Island

“Loved the farmers market, some of the local vendors that I spoke with were very friendly and knowledgeable about the area and the stuff they were selling. Great stop while exploring the area.”

4.3 Superb9 Reviews

“This is such a funny/lovely little grocery.It reminded me of the small town grocery store from the 2007 flop, "The Mist." It also has shockingly good music playing throughout the store. I found myself dancing several times in the aisles only to catch of a glimpse of several other shoppers doing the same. What a riot!”

3.4 Good55 Reviews

“Always clean, well stocked, and well organized—and since winter 2025, much more intuitively arranged!

Checkout lines sometimes get backed up.”

4.1 Good94 Reviews

“They got amazing steaks here. Carlos always so friendly and knowledgeable about steaks. Wagyu and Picanha are the best ones. No more red horse for me and my family!!!”

4 Good73 Reviews

“I want to give a special thanks to the assistant store manger Patrick Caporuscio moving to this town, every time I have gone in there he’s been incredibly helpful, professional and has made my day! Thank you Patrick for your compassion and hard work it’s appreciated in this small town”

4 Good105 Reviews

“I use their online service every week. They are professional and knowledgeable. The team knows what to substitute when the items I order are not in stock. The delivery driver is friendly.”

4 Good153 Reviews

Related topics