“This store always has everything I need. I have 3 dogs and they don't eat the same food.. it's nice to be able to get everything in one place. The staff always greet you kindly when you walk in, and they are always ready to help you when you need assistance.”
“The employees of Pets Supplies Plus in Medford, NY location are always happy to help me with my purchases. Erik and Ren are exceptional workers. The items are always in stock. If not on the shelves they check in back to see what they have. Customer service is top priority plus excellent prices. Always will go back there for my cat food and litter. Christine”
“An old town favorite that has been there for generations. Very nice to have a mom & pop store with such personable people still in business. Great selection of salt & fresh water fish and more. If anything, check out their axolotl babies! So cool.”
“I have used them for years for some of our dogs whole lives with no problems at all! I have 3 dogs now mostly large breeds and they do such a good job cleaning them and doing their nails.”
“My wife and I own a horse farm in Ridge. For several years now I've been making the run to Neptune every weekend to the point that the staff knows me by name. They carry grain brands like Triumph pellets that are hard to find elsewhere on Long Island.”
“Awesome produce options, standard grocery pickups and good selection of general goods. Location is great. Be prepared for self checkout as its faster than the live cashier options. Bring your own bags”
“For a chain store, this one outshines most others. Always clean and well stocked with personable people. They also have a dog trainer (Jade) that is full of knowledge and great to work with. There always seems to be a sale going on as well. I am big into aquariums and this store does not disappoint.”
“I had a great experience here today. I came in with my daughter who is turning 3 in a few days. She’s been asking for a pet bunny for her birthday and after unsuccessfully checking chain stores in the area, I realized that this place was in our town and only a couple miles from our house. I didn’t know what to expect going in but had a wonderful experience. It’s much bigger of a store than I thought it would be and the staff were all extremely friendly and welcoming of a toddler coming in without a stroller. I held my daughter at first as we acclimated and then put her down when we got to the bunnies. All of the staff members who came by us were smiling and in great spirits with good customer service. Once I told someone we were interested in buying a bunny, a female customer service rep helped me and my daughter by giving us all of the information I need to know about bringing home a bunny and she was incredibly patient in letting my little girl pet the available bunnies and decide which she wanted. She was extremely knowledgeable about the bunnies and their policies and procedures for buying one. We made our deposit at the front desk with another rep who was great. We are so excited to pick up our new bunny in a few days and am so glad to know of this gem right by our house!”
“Had such a great shopping experience today with Pete!!! He helped me and my mom by lifting a large Blackstone grill (not just the one on the top - she wanted the one that was 3 boxes down). He was so kind, making sure we had the right cart & helping to entertain my daughter. When we checked out, Pete bought my daughter a little stuffed horse that she absolutely loved and then he helped us lift the grill (and of the other stuff we bought) into the car and then took both our carts back for us. We tried to give him a tip and he wouldn't accept it. What an extremely kind, helpful human - he absolutely made our day!”
11AM - 7PM
1177 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island
Pet Stores
“My collie was groomed there today first time visit. Lauren did a beautiful job and she smells wonderful. I will definitely come back and share the great news. Thank you.?”
“In a world where it’s all about money & business, this store is an exemption. Giving 10 stars for the owner who took his time to show us around & gave us a neon tetra glow fish for free to “start us on the right track” Prices compared to Petco & Petsmart are waaay cheaper. And the variety of fishes there is in the store was a plus! We will definitely be back for future needs.”
“Super friendly and prices are very reasonable. It was my first visit, and I was not disappointed. Yesterday, someone told me about this miracle liquid for dogs with leg and hip pain. I have high hopes.”