-
July 2025 by George P
Kyle helped me figure out what I was looking for (trade paperbacks versus comics), and I feel like I got some good deals at 5$ a pop (like the full Watchmen trade paperback). Don't let the basement entrance deter you!
-
July 2025 by Shawn Kaufman
Kyle always has great books in stock and his prices are fair market value.
-
July 2025 by Donald Gallerani
Kyle was generous with his time and experience on grading comic books.
-
July 2025 by J. A.
Just got back from Kyle's comics. I had reached out to him last year and sent some photos of comics I had in hand at the time. I reached out to him recently to drop by with some comics my father-in-law had. Kyle took the time to look through them, knowing we were not looking to sell today, and educated us on the comics, condition, etc.
We understand he needs to buy/sell as part of his business but he did not pressure us into anything and gave us an idea on how to make the most with what we had if we wanted to sell on our own.
I plan to visit again when I come across all the better comics we have within the family.
Thank you!
-
June 2025 by Jennifer Hoolan
Kyle is amazing!! He helped me and my siblings sell my late father's comic collection. He was very communicative and walked us through the process. He is also extremely trustworthy and keeps his word. I would recommend doing business with Kyle if you need any help or advice about comics!
-
June 2024 by Ward Pickow
Kyles comics is great! Huge selection of CGC and unslabbed comics! Very friendly environment to just hang out, have great conversations with Kyle and other comic collectors and buy some great comics at a great deal!! Glad my nephew introduced me to this comic store! A must for any comic collector!!! They have comic supplies too!! Check it out!!!!
-
June 2024 by Donny Howe
Great person, & a fantastic business! Very happy with my experience working with Kyle to get my comics graded. He goes above and beyond to ensure his customer’s satisfaction. I could not ask for more & look forward to doing plenty of business in the future with Kyle. I highly recommend. A+++
-
June 2024 by William Baranello
Kyle is super friendly and very professional. My buddy and I got our comics graded through Kyle and he was very professional and trust worthy through the whole process and the prices were extremely fair . This is the only comic place I would personally deal with . Kyle is also extremely knowledgeable about comics and how they might grade .
-
May 2024 by Christopher Weber
Without a doubt the best comic book shop on Long Island - Kyle is super friendly and there is always amazing stuff to browse through.
-
May 2024 by Adolfo Menjivar
Friendly and knowledgeable in comics, Great prices...
-
May 2024 by David Hungie
I had ten comics graded by CBC and Kyle made things super easy to submit them.
-
April 2024 by Justine Hoffmann
Great guy gave me a comic for a good report card my son wrote he says he loves going with his dad and brother
-
March 2024 by Vince C
Super friendly, knowledgeable great variety. Great deals to fill the gap in my collection.
-
March 2024 by Michael Vinas
Great place to find vintage comics from all decades. Super friendly staff, and great specials on comics. Will visit again soon.
-
March 2024 by Frank N.
Kyle is an awesome guy! Fair, honest, and really knows his stuff! Spent lots of time analyzing and critiquing a ton of books. Came to a fair and equitable transaction for both parties. Buy and sell with No hesitation with Kyle !!
