-
March 2024 by Gwynne Doherty
Southold fish market is in iconic part of my childhood! This place has truly the best staff and seafood!
-
March 2024 by Carol M
Fresh and delicious! The best Peconic Bay scallops cooked to perfection. Amazing fried flounder. We will be back.
-
February 2024 by Samuel Mack
This place is great i tryed the new england clam chowder and the hamburger and the Interior décor is awsome
-
December 2023 by ruthann schiavone
Lunch was busy but not rushed. The food delious
-
December 2023 by Elliot Hoare
We had the new England chowder and the special of the day- Lobster BLT. All freshly made with delicious seafood, and good quality beer. Great spot for seafood on the North fork!There is both indoor and outdoor seating too which is great in the summer ☀️
-
December 2023 by Liz D
A Courteous young man helped me purchase 6 pounds of fillets. He was quick, prompt happy to help us. I might have been in the store a total of 15 minutes. It was a pleasure. I went in knowing exactly what I needed, located it asked for help. Packaged, rang up and on my way home.Thank you!!
-
November 2023 by Mike H.
The food was fresh and delicious.My wife and I sat and ate We purchased soup and baked clams to go for later also. This was our first time here but we'll be returning for sure.
-
November 2023 by Rohini G.
Great market and prepared food. Tried the oyster basket and fish and chips. The batter on the fish and chips was light but less crispy. The fish was very fresh. The oysters were also lightly breaded and fried and the salad was very fresh. The hard cider they served was also very smooth and light. Would come back and recommend to anyone visiting the north fork!
-
October 2023 by Theo Heinz
This place is great every time my wife and I come here it’s always busy because the food is really good. Lobster rolls are always stuffed and the oysters are always shucked to perfectly. The sandwiches are good as well, and even if you don’t get anything they make you can always buy the ingredients and bring them home. Our go to spot.
-
October 2023 by Em B.
This is literally the best seafood place I've ever ate at. No one compares. I literally crave SFM. They also have delicious specials all the time. Since this is an update, I can say that the people at the front definitely have changed their attitudes. We always enjoy coming here and thank you SFM for always putting out TOP QUALITY food.
-
October 2023 by M Scotto
Wow, wow, wow! Amazing food and fish. So incredibly fresh. Ordered the seafood wrap and grilled mahi tacos to split between the 2 of us and it did not disappoint. Everything was great from the coleslaw to the tomatoes on the salad. I wish I took pictures (I usually do but was so hungry, they were gone by the time I remembered!) I did take pictures of their beautiful selection of fish. Oh, and their very friendly helpful and patient staff was just as great!
-
October 2023 by Mike Weiner
Very nice menu, really good food, seat yourself inside or out. Friendly service.
-
September 2023 by Will Joe
Food is excellent. But portions are small and prices a little high.
-
September 2023 by Ines P
Many options, even for those of us on a budget. They don't label spices, which is a concern. Many seafood dishes have paprika as an ingredient--one of us absolutely cannot have it! The young woman at register grimaces when I order a half pound of this or that. As if it troubles her that I'm not spending enough money. Actually, $40 is a lot for me. It's relative, I suppose.
-
September 2023 by Valentino B Borrelli Jr.
What great place. You have to also try the Manhattan and New England clam chowder. It's outstanding. I got a bowl of each. I loved everything.❤️??
