-
March 2024 by Mia Patel
Great things, great prices, owners are very friendly!
-
February 2024 by maria myagkova
I really love this store, even though I don’t live nearby. Great things, great prices, owners are very friendly! Every time I leave with my purchases I am delighted! Thank you, guys!!
-
December 2023 by Joseph
Very unhappy with my experience here. I would not recommend going to this thrift store. The owner is very nasty and ungrateful. The staff is also extremely nasty. If I could give this store zero stars I would.
-
November 2023 by Michelle Riccardi
I have been going to nothing new thrift shop for several years, from their first locations to their latest location. Through the years, I have always dealt with the owner Jodi, who is an absolute ANGEL. Her staff are all wonderful as well. Dina, Nella & Faith are simply AMAZING. They are friendly, personable, helpful, and accommodating. When you walk into nothing new thrift shop, you’re not just going there to buy secondhand, it’s like catching up with friends. You’re always greeted with a smile and they genuinely seem happy to see you. I will be a customer there for the rest of my life.
-
August 2023 by Grace M.
so disappointed.....the old nothing new across the street was amazing. 2 floors, amazing diverse collection, well organized. a tiny bit pricey, but felt worth it for the experience. the clothes were gorgeous, high quality, vintage. then they opened up nothing new II across the street, which wasn't great, disorganized, kinda small, but i thought whatever. they just opened up, they'll get more stuff and it'll be great.now? they closed the original nothing new. there's only the 2nd store, now just called nothing new. it's terrible. they're displaying cheap, STAINED forever 21 clothes. i saw a knit dress with a huge stain being sold for $50. so many stained clothes too. cheap shirts are being sold for $10. it's outrageous. everything is fast fashion, very little vintage. not to mention everything is incredibly disorganized, crowded, and thoughtless. yet there's barely a quarter of the amount of clothes in the old store. (not half, since there's one less floor-- a QUARTER. the old one really optimized its space. the new one does not.)just terrible. terrible selection, cheaply made stained clothes sold for $15, disorganized, everything. just wow.
-
July 2023 by May Lina
I’m not sure why it’s not posted online, the fact that it was closed or they have moved. (Sign says “we moved across the street” but across the street was a veterinarian clinic). At least post the new address. The restaurant blocked off that portion. But thank you for replying will be passing by. Thank You
-
June 2023 by Matt Cohen
I always have the best time when going to Nothing New to shop! Jodi and John are amazing and their staff Nella and Dina are just incredible and very friendly. When you walk into nothing new you will always find something new and incredible! There’s always something great to find! I would recommend Nothing New to Everyone! This is the best place to shop in Staten Island, better than department stores!
-
April 2023 by Kay M.
Neat place for odds and ends! Got some cool shoes. Really glad I checked this place out.
-
April 2023 by Amanda Sica-Irizarry
have tried many times to give this store a chance, however, there are better thrifts out there and after my experience with the owner today, I was appalled. I reached on a top shelf to take down a dish with a sculpture. The items on the top shelf were wobbly and another large ceramic item came down at me. In turn I dropped the item I was holding and it broke. In a normal situation, a person working would have asked if I was okay. Instead, the owner made a snarky remark towards me stating "10 years and 15 minutes of the item in the store and this is what happens." She then proceeded to say "This is why we can"t drive while on our cell phones." referring to me because I was on the phone while it happened. The phone however was not the cause; lack of proper staging/displaying in an unstable way was. I responded back "And that's why you can't put wobbly items on the top shelf either."I offered to pay for the item as well that broke. Another worker then came over and removed items from the top that she herself noted were not flat on the bottom and could also fall. my plan was to visit the other location afterwards, but Inwas so taken back at the inappropriate response I received, I decided to spend my money elsewhere.I have never seen such a lack of concern for the well being of others and her only concern was the item marked $5 that broke. I actually hurt my finger, but passing blame was the only thing on her agenda today. Extremely rude and poor customer service.**On a side note, the other ladies that work this location are usually very nice and she should be thankful because they obviously keep the business going and keep customers going back.
-
April 2023 by Amanda S.
have tried many times to give this store a chance, however, there are better thrifts out there and after my experience with the owner today, I was appalled. I reached on a top shelf to take down a dish with a sculpture. The items on the top shelf were wobbly and another large ceramic item came down at me. In turn I dropped the item I was holding and it broke. In a normal situation, a person working would have asked if I was okay. Instead, the owner made a snarky remark towards me stating "10 years and 15 minutes of the item in the store and this is what happens." She then proceeded to say "This is why we can"t drive while on our cell phones." referring to me because I was on the phone while it happened. The phone however was not the cause; lack of proper staging/displaying in an unstable way was. I responded back "And that's why you can't put wobbly items on the top shelf either." I offered to pay for the item as well that broke. Another worker then came over and removed items from the top that she herself noted were not flat on the bottom and could also fall. my plan was to visit the other location afterwards, but Inwas so taken back at the inappropriate response I received, I decided to spend my money elsewhere. I have never seen such a lack of concern for the well being of others and her only concern was the item marked $5 that broke. I actually hurt my finger, but passing blame was the only thing on her agenda today. Extremely rude and poor customer service. **On a side note, the other ladies that work this location are usually very nice and she should be thankful because they obviously keep the business going and keep customers going back.
-
April 2023 by E. K.
Great place, clean, organized, decent prices. Look forward to going there whenever in Staten Isl. Love the other one too!
-
September 2022 by Joseph Raspa
I bought a few things, and she only charged me for half of them. Always getting "new" stuff (for free), and she has to make room!
-
July 2022 by Michele Lynn Curto-Gredder
NOTHING NEW THRIFT SHOP is my “happy place!!” They have great deals!! Today was fill a bag for $20 or fill a bigger bag for $25!! LOVE THIS PLACE!!!?
-
June 2022 by Ben Brill
Amazing store! The (owner?) was so friendly and he gave a phenomenal deal for my items. Thanks!
-
May 2022 by Maria Aprile
Thank you so much for finding new owners for our treasures from Mom and Dad. You are providing a wonderful outlet for our community while at the same time helping us re-purpose and reuse. Thank you and God bless!
