-
January 2024 by Sol
The Bay St Top Tomato is very clean, organized & has very pleasant employees. I do all my shopping there on a weekly basis. I recently redeemed my receipts for a great deal being offered if you spend either $500 or $250, within a months time. I chose a 1/2 tray of Chicken Marsala as my gift & it was overstocked with chicken cutlet, super tender & over all delicious! If you need a pick up & go meal, they also have many to select from & I’ve never been disappointed. 5+ stars place!
-
December 2023 by Ryanmichaelnyc29
Used to be one of the best for sausage and meats and deliNot anymoreAlso very rude staff
-
September 2023 by George D.
I ordered from Bay Street top tomato twice for their family dinners. I will say they exceeded my expectations of how tasty the food was. I whole heartedly recommend this store.
-
July 2023 by Zenda D.
When I say amazing customer service I really and truly mean it. My favorite cashier is Jacqueline every time I pass by to purchase anything her smile and her spirit brightens my day. I went in today to grab a few things I was so happy to see her. The food here is always fresh and although it's a small store, it comes with plenty. The sales on water are none like no other. The ambiance is comfy feels like a mom and pops Italian restaurant. Being a traveler it's ideal to have stores like these when you are on the go. I greatly appreciate the service. Please promote Jacquelyn I'm thinking store manager. Her fruits of the spirit are fruiting!
-
May 2023 by Alex Sher
One of the standout features of this supermarket is the wide range of products available. From fresh produce and meats to pantry staples, household items, and personal care products, they have you covered. The shelves are well-stocked, ensuring that you can find everything on your shopping list in one place. The variety of brands and options cater to different preferences and dietary needs, making it convenient for customers with specific requirements.This supermarket provides a reliable shopping experience with its wide selection of products, convenient layout, and additional services. While there is room for improvement in customer service consistency, the supermarket's competitive pricing and overall cleanliness make it a preferred choice for everyday grocery shopping. Whether you're stocking up on essentials or exploring new ingredients, this supermarket offers a convenient and hassle-free shopping experience.
-
May 2023 by Matthew Huynh
Nice but don’t put your fliers under car wipers please.
-
May 2023 by Hope Wright
Love their homemade prepared foods! Deli department! Stuffed chicken breast, stuffed pork chops, stuffed portobello mushrooms, spinach quiche! Fabulous selection, and always fresh! So fortunate to have them right here on Bay Street!
-
October 2022 by M. F.
I BOUGHT SWISS CHEESE FOR $7.99 LBTHEY GAVE ME TARE. I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT IS. THE ITALIAN GUY AND THE MEXICAN GUY ARE POLITE BUT ALSO TRIED TO CHARGE ME $8.99 A LB.TOP TOMATO GET IT TOGETHER OK
-
October 2022 by Joe Cardone
Clean organized friendly not a big selection but You can make a great meal .
-
September 2022 by Evette Battle
I have been on Staten island for 30 yrs and this is the place to come from shopping to catering your event. They have awesome prices. Fresh fruits and vegetables everyday. Seasoned meats. Fresh pastry. I love the Deli department the guys their are awesome they are so engaging and helpful the deli food is so good. The Cold cuts combo prices are great. Today I finally I had the pleasure meeting Nick(owner). The store is so organized and so clean. Great job to your staff keep on smiling and being professional and courteous to your customers Nice in receiving 10 percent off as an health worker(RUMC) it made my day being recognized.Please let me know if you can donate holiday food baskets to our needy families for the holidays . We always order from your catering dept we look no further your the best Thank you!
-
August 2022 by Suzie R.
The re-opened top tomato is super. Very clean, still being stocked, very fresh breads, home made cakes. Hoping the new top tomato will be around for a very long time
-
July 2022 by MosesBruce Desai
First impressions it looks organized and clean.Prices are little over than other grocery markets.But they are scammers.Be careful check your groceries before you leave.I bought watermelon and 2 lemons.Now for two items you would think it would be in bag together.Well wrong you arrive at home and find out you just got watermelon and lemons they kept for themselves to enjoy some lemonade on customers expense.
-
June 2022 by Rus S
Don't buy any seafood in this store if you don't want to end up at a hospital. This seafood place has to be shot down for good due to an imminent hazard to the public health. Most of the seafood is far beneath the quality acceptance line.
-
May 2022 by Patricia Santanastaso
I catered food from Top Tomato , everything we ordered was absolutely delicious. I highly recommend Top Tomato for your catering needs. So delicious. I am going to order their breakfast catering for my next family gathering. ??
-
March 2022 by Thomas Vincent
I usually come here about once a month and spend close to almost $500 dollars in groceries the store is great good selection of stuff everything is fresh. But the Spanish guy who works at fish department was so rude acting very inconsiderate and rolling his eyes when we asking about certain seafoods. He was so rude we didn’t even want anything from seafood department he mumbled something to as well as we walked away. What a shame cause we actually loved the store the people from the cold cut section was very nice though. But because of how mad we got at the guy fromSeafood department we will no longer coming to this place.
