-
March 2024 by trexpar
We were traveling to a family reunion and wanted to stop off at a local brew pub on our way. The Wantagh inn fit the bill. We sat at the bar and had some delicious Guinness, we opted for the set lunch menu which was plenty of delicious food. The local crowd was friendly and gave us suggestions for our drive. I’ll be back when we gather again.
-
March 2024 by Corey B.
You will be treated extremely poorly by the bar tenders or completely ignored unless you're an attractive female or a white male over the age of 40.
-
March 2024 by drmole6575
Good food. Nice atmosphereParking: Parking is difficult.
-
February 2024 by Bob Barzyk
We had dinner at the bar on a Tuesday around 6pm and it had a really nice vibe. Everyone was friendly and was having a good time. Bartenders were great, too.
-
January 2024 by Art “A2Jr” Angst
Held an after funeral affair here. Overall good place. I had the stew, with I loved. Small amount of others weren't happy with their meals. Staff very attentive and helpful.Parking: Spots in back tough to navigate.
-
January 2024 by Missy G.
Food is ok, very very loud crowded and service is extremely slow! Sweet elder man seated us but we felt like we were a burden to get a drink or even the check.
-
January 2024 by Liz (Liz)
The food here is just okay. This is a restaurant/bar that's filled with people 50+. It is a good time, okay food. I've gotten only a beer or soda from here so I cannot speak on how their mixed drinks are. I've come here and been at the bar and also as a group in the restaurant area. The waitress did a phenomenal job catering to each of our 10 needs/orders and was timely and efficient.
-
January 2024 by Matt Seinberg
Finally got here after seeing it for years! My wife had the salmon, and I had the Jagerschitzel which was delicious! The owner seated us and the service was excellent. We can't wait to go back!UPDATE: April 30 2021. We went for the lunch Price Fixe menu today and once again the food was terrific. I had the chicken parm and my wife had the salmon again. Gotta go back again real soon!UPDATE: A friend and I went for lunch, and once again the food and service was terrific. I had the sliced roast beef and mashed potatoes, and he had a chicken ceaser salad that was huge!
-
December 2023 by Jennifer Baratta
After a funeral and burial services we went to celebrate Marion Soldo life.
-
December 2023 by Robin M.
Been there a few times. Music is way too loud in the bar area. Pricey menu for a bar. Probably due to Covid. So annoying but for me!!! no mayonnaise ever??? Can't go back. Waiter said they never have mayo.
-
December 2023 by Susan Gail
The pup style restaurant was very loud and the reception area was confusing. There was no place to wait except a loud bar with an enormous TV. When I didn’t want to sit by the noisy kitchen door I was told I would have to wait another 3 hours for a table bc they had no other. Then they showed me another spot outside which was even noisier so I took the previous table after I was told “I wasn’t going to win this one”I told her I didn’t know I was at war. (My daughter has sensory issues and cannot tolerate loud noises.)It took 2 hours and 50 minutes to have soup or salad, an entree and a dessert which she couldn’t bother telling us what our three choices were. We had to look at the menu and, again,wait for her return. The waitress never brought us our bill. We got up and stood by the cashier waiting to pay. When she finally showed up she said oh! Didn’t I give it to you?I gave her 20% of the subtotal which was far too generous.Wasthe food good?Yes, but certainly not worth the aggravation of waiting for everything including water, bread, cutlery and everything other thing described and being ignored by the entire waitstaff
-
December 2023 by Goots Baby
I reserved a room for 10 people. Catrine was my server. She was very rude and very obviously cutting off and being extra rude to the Hispanic and black tables she had. Afterwards the bus girl and wait staff were dropping plates and silverware on our table aggressively. Racist staff terrible service never coming here again.
-
November 2023 by Mary R.
Sorry to say our Thanksgiving dinner was awful! We have had dinner there in the past and it was good comfort food. Never great. My family of 5 had a terrible dinner there tonight with plate prices that are on par with NYC restaurants. Service was very good, as usual but the food was just so bad. What a waste of money. Never again, ruined the day!
-
November 2023 by Jane B.
DELICIOUS Thanksgiving Dinner!! Great menu and large portions. Our server Kathryn made this family very happy. We are never disappointed at the Wantagh Inn! Thank you!
-
November 2023 by L Br NY
Abysmal parking situation. Very nice main dining room for family gatherings. I attended a baby shower upstairs. Only one server working entire party, so patience was needed! Very weird bathroom placement; right behind hostess station. Only two stalls for entire restaurant. Not at all wheelchair friendly. Salmon made my stomach a bit queasy for remainder of day.
