What's In Your Attic is the best store for antiques and collectibles in Western New York. Customers have been buying video games and enjoying the newly expanded McKinley Mall location for many years. The store is praised for its professionalism, courtesy, and the extra mile they go to serve their customers, making them lifelong customers. Customers love checking the store for amazing funkos, vintage toys, DVDs, sports memorabilia, games, and much more, despite slightly higher prices. The owner is described as amazing and very helpful, with tons of great, interesting items to explore.
This was a great shop! ADHD-AF! Something for everybody. Antiques, games, figurines, Live Fish(!?!?), books, random shiznit, RECORDS out the wazzoo, books, collectables, etceterarama. Hot dang. Super happy we meandered into this place while on a road trip. :)
May 2026
Best store in the mall will hopefully be back again
April 2026
Amazing and helpful staff, but to top it off it’s the coolest store I know! Will be back, hopefully my next paycheck
