Prime Time Butcher, a family-owned and operated business in Woodbury, New York, has been serving the community for over thirty years. Renowned for its high-quality meats, it is one of the few exclusive purveyors of Dry Aged Prime Beef, along with American Lamb, and All Natural Poultry, Beef, and Pork—all hand-selected from top USDA suppliers. Every item is hand-cut in the traditional way, trimmed and wrapped to customer specifications, with expert cooking instructions included for perfect results. The shop offers a variety of cooked foods, from classic recipes to fresh starters, mains, and sides. Customers praise the freshness, tender meats, and excellent taste, often comparing their steaks and burgers to those at high-end steakhouses. The staff, including Lou and Josh, are friendly, helpful, and go out of their way to provide great service. The quality of prepared foods like ribs, baked chicken tenders, and holiday treats is highly appreciated, making Prime Time Butcher a top choice for meat lovers on Long Island.
Amazing first experience the owner Lou is an absolute sweetheart and knows his stuff! The meat is top quality and fresh and the store is super clean. Prices are reasonable and worth it for the quality of meat and service you get. I’m a customer for life now and will not go anywhere else. Best butcher on Long Island hands... read full comment
October 2024
The feta/spinach and cheddar/broccoli chicken burgers were outstanding as were the turkey burgers. The freshness stands out with minimal seasoning. Lou is an outstanding guy to deal with. The BBQ is great too along with the sides. Yours truly, The Big fan.
October 2024
First time here and can't wait to come back. Wonderful staff, great meat and fabulous experience.
