June 2020 by Toni McCance
After a long, hot day at the beach, the delicious food was just what our family needed. Everything was cooked special order, which means it was served hot and fresh. The French fries are some of the best I have eaten. The customer service was top-notch. The lady taking orders was very friendly.
June 2020 by Jd Taylor
Best deluxe pizza, definitely coming back every trip to emerald isle!!
June 2020 by Heather Lamp
We have eaten here several times and every time the food is fresh, hot, and taste so good. It's a great pizza place but by far the BEST cheeseburger on the island.
April 2020 by Amanda Watts
Got the buffalo chicken pizza and hot wings ! Absolutely delicious! Fast and friendly service too :)
March 2020 by Brittney Ames
Have called this place multiple times today and the day before and no one once answered the phone.
December 2019 by John Dowless
It was the last day of the season so they didn't have a lot of products gyros with no saucewe ordered a pizza the sauce on the pizza was very bland the dough was very moist even though they said it was fresh dough made daily I don't think so we'll try it again when the season starts since I live 15 minutes away.
December 2019 by Ted Yoder
Great tasting food... wonderful service
December 2019 by jimmy cook
Nothing good to say except our waitress was very nice and overworked.
December 2019 by Lee Whorley
Great food wonderful service
December 2019 by Nick&Sarah Barkan
Got 2 pizzas and 2 sides. Was very good.
October 2019 by Shelby Turner
First time visiting this place the first day we eat here was great waitress was wonderful it was around lunch time Johnnie hope the name is right apologize if I didn't get name right was a blast. So we decided that we would try again a couple days later. Was not the same order pizza took over 45 minutes to receive it and the waitress never bothered to tell us it got messed up the first time do it had to be redone which would not have been bad if we had some communication about what was going on. Food was good but we ended up getting it to go due to everyone else with us had done eat.
October 2019 by Angelareckley
Looking for Great pizza and great customer service? This is it! Best pizza on the Isle! Lots of choices and very yummy.
October 2019 by Josh B.
We love this place. Most the pizza in this area is either a national chain or New York style pizza. I prefer Circle Pizza over New York style every time. We love their crust. Their burgers are great too. The prices here are far better than the New York style pizza places as well. Our order has never been messed up despite my wife customizing everything. The only reason I wouldn't give it 5 stars is because the inside seating is really quiet with no music or TVs playing and they just have a few bottled beers to select from (who cares though). I could write more but this is our go to pizza place in the Carteret area.
September 2019 by shelby mack
Awesome delivery guy! Said they weren't supposed to deliver to where I am but they did and I appreciate that! Food is delicious. Thank you.
September 2019 by Lisa McGee
Pizza is pretty good. Service needs help! Always too busy!
September 2019 by cyled2014
Pizza was bland, Italian sub was tasteless, salad was average. Customer service was lacking and several employees in the back were having inappropriate conversations that anyone out front could and did hear.
August 2019 by Manuel Flores
Called in order 4 pizza's & 2 philly steak. $82.00 Showed up at 45 minute mark only to wait 45 additional minutes with no one in the store Saturday night at 7pm except the other 3 or 4 call in orders equally frustrated. The waitresses were arguing with the back. I asked why it took so long, "its always like this". Pizza had good taste but because of the wait and nonchalant attitude, we will not be going back.
August 2019 by Earl Anderson
Service with a smile here, plus excellent pizza. We had the meat lovers pizza, which had tons of meat and cheesy goodness. We also had the buffalo chicken pizza, which again had anyone of cheese and a perfect spiciness. Lastly we added cheese fries that again had a great amount of cheese. To top it all off the staff were amazing and super friendly. We will be adding Circle Pizza to our return places to always visit!
August 2019 by 81jenl
Loved this place before they moved. Still love them. I get the ham and cheese sub. Tried the burger this thin. It was huge and hand pattied. Small and quaint with local art displayed. Same family as years back with the son taking over. Love this place. . Great food!!!!
August 2019 by Robert K.
Was told that delivery would take 2 hours so we decided to pick up instead and get it in 45-60min. We showed up 45 mins after we placed the order and ended up waiting another 45 mins. They kept on telling us 5 more minutes knowing they hadn't started on the order yet. When we finally got our pizza back home, we found out they messed up our order. Ordered pizza with sausage and got mushrooms instead. So an hour and a half for the wrong pizza that tasted like it came from the public school cafeteria. Don't believe the positive reviews. Stay away.
July 2019 by Ashleigh P.
I feel bad giving this place 2 stars because everyone was so nice. But this has got to be some of the worst pizza I've ever had. It is definitely a freezer pizza. I would go elsewhere if you're actually craving pizza. If you just need a hot meal where your kids can be as loud or messy as they want, this works.
July 2019 by Mr. S.
This place is not very sanitary at all. I was shocked by a large roach crawling over my flip flop while dining in. The floor staff did not seem too enthusiastic about their jobs as if they hated doing them. After coming for months I have noticed the same poop-colored thumbprint over the flush handle of the toilet in the men's room which has never gone away since my family and I started coming. Delivery is slow and I have been told 1.5 hour wait times on the phone only to have my meal delivered to me cold and burnt later than that. At other local businesses that serve pizza in EI I have never had more than a 45 minute projected wait time and would get my pizza hot. The parking lot is a wreck the employees not only park disorderly but fly carelessly into the active parking lot where I've nearly been hit before. The dining area feels too hot. On the flip side the pizza is great but only if you dine in while it is hot. The burgers are also very good. Best fries on the island but terrible experience.
July 2019 by Michael S.
Really disappointed in this place. Food service slow then was informed that they were out of ham for my italian sub. FINALLY get out food and sub was overdone and dry! Ask why no Italian dressing on sub and THEN was informed that they were out of that too! Would have been nice to know that when order was placed! Service sucked, food sucked will NOT BE GOING BACK! OH YEAH....we weren't the only complaints. Heard 2 other tables complain and there was only 3 other tables taken! WHATS WRONG WITH THESE FOLKS??? I'll stick with Michelangelo's!
July 2019 by Dennis1952
Let me cut to the chase. Don’t go! Read the â€œClueless â€œ and Apologetic Staffâ€ reviews . This was my experience. I waited 45 minutes for two manicotti dinners and a small cheese/tomato pizza take out order. Photos posted. I went there to order after trying to order by phone (my fault should have known then not to go there). Got my $30 order. The manicotti was tasteless and cold. The cheese/tomato was cold and soggy with oil. The entire front is ran by one lady (orders, server, cleans, etc). I live full time at EI. I have gone there during the off season and never had this experience. Never again!
July 2019 by Adam Wethington
Quite literally the absolute worst restaurant I've ever encountered. The booth seating looks to be made of reclaimed pallets and is quite uncomfortable. I ordered a chicken salad that was served on a styrofoam plate (classy). It consisted of bagged iceberg lettuce, 2 micro thin slices of tomato, green pepper, and red onion. It was topped with scorched bits of fried chicken. The pizza was topped with rubbery cheese and the crust was soggy. While we sat there eating, a take out customer came to pick up pizza only to find the pizza was burnt. She ended up leaving with the burnt pizza and paid full price due to the lack of proper customer service. On a positive note, it was clean and the staff was polite.
July 2019 by Nikki Westerfield
Food was SO good!!! The waitress was very friendly she said she had only been working for a couple of days. The other older lady was so attentive to our every need. Honestly way above and beyond then she needed to be. We felt very important at our first time at this place. Pizza was delicious. 10 stars!!!
July 2019 by Scott Vejnar
This was really good pizza for a beach day. Not over priced. It is very worth it.
July 2019 by April dalton
I've had a little of everything on the menu n it's all great. Philly cheese steak is amazing
July 2019 by Gregory Keech
Very poor service!! Waited 30 minutes and still no one had even acknowledged we were there! We eventually had to walk to the counter to get our drinks and then waited another 10 minutes before we were acknowledged but still not waited on! From now on we will be sticking with Michael Angelo's or Luigi's!!!
July 2019 by Jorden Sauls
Food is good. But service is not the best. Took a hour to get a chicken sandwich and haven’t seen the manager either. Come on people.