Sheetz of Fayetteville offers a unique blend of convenience and quality, open 24/7 to serve customers with a variety of options. The store features award-winning Made•To•Order® food and Sheetz Bros. Coffeez® drinks, making it a go-to spot for late-night or odd-hour meals. Customers appreciate the decent food quality for the price and the affordability of gas, especially with a loyalty card.
The staff at this location is frequently praised for their friendliness and hard work, providing exceptional customer service. However, there are some concerns regarding security, as incidents of theft have been reported without adequate measures in place to address them. While most orders are fulfilled correctly, there have been occasional mix-ups, particularly during busy times when the staff appears rushed.
Overall, Sheetz of Fayetteville is recognized for its clean and well-organized environment, making it a reliable choice for snacks, drinks, and fuel, along with a welcoming atmosphere thanks to its dedicated employees.
My gas station number 1 ,I notice the gas in sheetz is prolonged better than Murphy in my car tank same route every day ,for some reason the vapor in Murphy is more high then sheetz . 2 days in sheetz and I have almost fill thank 2 days Murphy and almost 1/2 tank is gone same route ,same velocity, same time.
September 2026
Ms. Ayana was absolutely amazing. Shes funny, kind, attentive, and fast. Deserves a promotion
May 2026
Great customer service! Amazing food, especially the tacos! This place has everything! Why the Sheetz not? By the way, the guy behind the glass was so nice and helpful. I wanted to give him a shout out because this is my first time to ever be here and he was happy to explain what I needed to do. Thank you!
