-
March 2024 by Reid Kurylo
I got a new item on the “Tuesdays specials” which was the buffalo chicken dip and it was perfect.
-
March 2024 by Lisa
Great pizza and garlic knots! Superb delivery service!
-
March 2024 by Brian Wehner
Great pizza shop right off of Colington Road.
-
February 2024 by Cjt
Food is unbelievably over priced and subpar is taste. Do you need to be reminded pizza is sauce flour water and cheese? 25$ for a pizza, 10$ for garlic rolls lol. 13$ for 6 wings?
-
February 2024 by David Reichelderfer
Italian sandwich was much smaller than expected for the price. Where’s the meat?
-
December 2023 by joe trenary
The food was excellent, fresh they were not relaxed on quality or quantity. This is definitely my new go to when we get in town.
-
December 2023 by Glenn Rainey
Great locally-owned pizza restaurant with a variety of sandwiches and appetizers too. Good selection of draft beer, several can / bottle options plus wine. Small, friendly place offering dine in, take out and delivery.Several TV'S usually with a variety of sports.
-
November 2023 by Jennifer B.
Colington is rated "Best Pizza on the Beach" and our first experience was delicious. We ordered a supreme pizza and a Greek salad. Both were fabulous. The supreme pizza has sliced meatballs and red onion on it -- tasty touches. The salad dressing for the Greek salad was an outstanding vinaigrette that seemed to be homemade. We ordered online and our food was ready in twenty minutes. When we walked in to pick it up, our food was waiting for us and the staff was very friendly. Colington offers some really great food!!
-
September 2023 by Corey Martin
New ownership and management are doing a great job! Dinner and even brunch is amazing.
-
September 2023 by Mark C.
Went to Collington Pizza because they advertised a Jazz Band playing on 9/9/23. Not going to rate the band, as they were all local senior citizens trying their best. My wife and I both ordered cheesesteaks. Undoubtedly the worse cheesesteak I've ever had. The meat was tasteless, very little cheese, and about as greasy of a sandwich as I have ever had. Also ordered the specialty fries from the appetizer menu. They were a disaster. Heavily coated with pepper, very little cheese, and what cheeses that was on there was cheese whiz. Totally disgusting. The only bright spot was the young waitress that was checking in on us while we tried to eat. Pleasant personality. Unfortunately, we didn't go for pleasant personality, we went for what was billed as a Jazz Band, and some decent food. We got neither.....
-
August 2023 by Christie Bell
We came to Collington Pizza during our mini vacation trip for our 23rd Anniversary. This restaurant was top notch! They were so attentive and friendly. Even the owner came by our table and talked with us. Before I ordered, I asked our waitress if the Margherita pizza was made correctly....with fresh basil???? And she said "yes, the chef uses my basil that I grow myself". I was thrilled! So, of course, I ordered the Margherita pizza. My husband ordered a customized pizza. Our pizzas were the best pizzas we have ever eaten! The crust is thin and airy! The sauce is perfection! Our waitress, Rhi, was the best server we have had in 10 years! She was outstanding! After our meal, she asked which dessert we preferred, something chocolate or cheesecake. We were torn, but we both love cheesecake, so we asked for that. It was a blueberry cobbler cheesecake!!!! And oh my goodness....it was the best cheesecake ever, hands down! This place is fire! I was so impressed that I tipped the chef! My husband and I highly recommend Collington Pizza! You will not be disappointed!!!!
-
August 2023 by Brandon Boulding
We ordered take our our first night on the island and we're delighted by the food we recieved. Unique combinations that were very tasty!
-
August 2023 by Dave Moore
CPBG fries. So yummy!
-
July 2023 by Michelina Crawford
The friendliest and most attentive staff I’ve ever encountered. Ordered pizza to go and it was a quick wait I got to see how they interacted with many customers that came in and they were equally wonderful with everyone. It also helps that the pizzas and dough fritters were VERY good!!
-
July 2023 by Russ Linville
Friendly staff and good food. Our server even brought us a sample of something they were experimenting with. Sausage gravy on a pizza. I would never have thought of it but it was very good!
