-
March 2024 by Jordan Romero
Best pies I’ve ever had in my life. Nothing comes close.
-
February 2024 by Rachel Morris
The best key lime pie around!
-
January 2024 by Taylor Jacoby
Wife and I are sampling the best pies of the triangle, and this place came highly recommended. After getting a half apple pie for the 2 of us, we were very disappointed. Pie was very over priced, the filling was lackluster and the crust was dry and lacked flavor.***Update***The owner personally reached out to me to talk about our experience, and was great to speak to!
-
December 2023 by Jason H.
We picked up three pies the day before Thanksgiving, pumpkin, pecan and sweet potato. Surprisingly, there was no line, though the cheerful checker told us there had been when they opened a few hours before. Arriving later didn't hurt us; they were fully stocked up on everything.Taste-wise, the pumpkin and pecan were decent standard versions, but the sweet potato ROCKED! I loved that it wasn't too sweet and not overly spiced--the flavors of nutmeg and sweet potato came through.
-
November 2023 by cathleen labate
I ordered an apple pie from this wonderful company, for my brother in law. He is in hospice care, and his time on earth is coming to a close. I told him about the pie, which I ordered from Goldbelly, and gold belly said delivery was on Tuesday. He was heart broken...small things like his favorite pie, mean so much when you are so ill....I reached out to Kristen, the owner, and OMG, she had the pie delivered Wednesday morning. To their door! Granted, they live the next town over, but still, amazing customer service. My brother in law texted me as soon as he opened the box...anyway, Kristen's kindness brought me to tears! And the best part? Joe said it was the best apple pie he ever ate! Something about the crust being really flaky! People are always in a hurry nowadays...so to have a company pay attention to a really small matter, and solve the problem immediately, is a blessing and a joyful experience.! I want to thank Slice Pie Company, from the bottom of my heart, for their extra special kindness towards my brother in law! I am humbled!
-
November 2023 by Jessie Harris
I wish I could give more stars. Best pie I’ve ever had. I won’t be eating pie from anywhere else ever!!!
-
November 2023 by David Jackson
When I walked in, the lady at the front had the best energy. She went over all their pie selections with me. I chose the sweet potato pie, and was not disappointed, it was very good.
-
November 2023 by Jenny Estes
Really good pie. Tried their apple pie, level of cinnamon was just right. Apples perfectly thinly sliced and great texture (not mushy). Their crust is just not my favorite. It needs to be flakier or more buttery, I think. Something is missing. But still better than I can make at home so 4 stars in my book.
-
November 2023 by Moises A.G
We bought a few different pies to try, blueberry, pumpkin and pecan. All of them were great! Only reason I’m taking a star is due to the prices. Not cheap for 2 slices and a half of pie. $45 with tax.
-
November 2023 by Laura Jack
Great customer service! Average tasting pie for the price. Sell me on the visual. Feel like the pies are hidden in the small fridge. Google Oakmont Bakery in PA for displaying ideas.
-
November 2023 by Jill Browne
Excellent excellent excellent! We had 3 slices of pie: apple, chocolate peanut butter, and pumpkin. They were all delicious. I highly recommend.
-
October 2023 by Randy Parnell
They have some of the most unique-tasting pies around. I really enjoyed the coconut cream pie.
-
October 2023 by AnnaRae Wood
The pie here is amazing! I have tried many of their flavors and I can genuinely say I havent had one I disliked. I am not a fan of coconut but I tired a bit of a friends and actually enjoyed it. Will definitely be ordering my pies from here in the future.
-
September 2023 by Mr C.
This place was a random find. But the blubbery cheesecake (might be describing it wrong ) pie was very good. The customer service was very good and the pies tasted fresh. The only reason it was not 5 stars is because 7 dollars for a slice of pie is a bit much. But I will say check the place out
-
September 2023 by Berna j.
Nothing short of amazing! I had the lemon pie with raspberry glaze. I HAVE NEVER HAD A PIE LIKE THIS IN MY LIFE. This is not your typical congealed lemon...this was a creamy....yes! CREAMY LEMON....pie with a raspberry top. Mind you I had it over the weekend and I'm still thinking about this pie. The creator of this masterpiece has mastered pie crust making. The crust (bottom crust) was a beautiful golden brown and flaky. Not soggy! The best part.....they sell slices...yesssss honey.... A slice of pie. Now you can go try them all! I also had a slice of mixed berry. Yes, that was just as good but that lemon....hit like I ate it so fast I didn't even get a chance to take a picture. No worries I will go back....promise to take a pic before I endulge.