-
March 2024 by john neuding
This location likes to put barley any toppings on there pizza don't waste you're time an go to Circleville or lancaster
-
March 2024 by Ashton Myers
Ol' Jelly Roll says it best, "Never let me down"
-
March 2024 by Melissa Taylor
I have always loved Cristy's Pizza since I was a kid growing up in Lancaster. Their pizza is always amazing and quality very consistent and great. I'm super cheap though and sometimes they're just a little out of my range especially without deals or coupons, but I highly recommend for a great pizza!Vegetarian options: They even offer a cauliflower crust pizza for vegans or gluten free option
-
December 2023 by Johny L.
Food was horrible and cold and workers don't Wear gloves... I will never go back and I advise everyone else not to order from there ..shit is disgusting
-
December 2023 by Lori Mcgath
I don't want to give a star at all.Management there is rude, nasty mouth, Last time I was there .I swore I'd never go back..it's been months now...I even decided not to buy my pizza or sub that day..Sorry for the bad review..I'd never given anyplace a bad report unless it was truly that bad.
-
December 2023 by Steve Hill
Everything was luke warm to cold tonight, live 2 blocks away
-
December 2023 by Stacey Freeman
The last probably 5 times we've ordered the pizza was terrible. Sauce tasted spoiled or something. Barely any toppings. Had a half off coupon and was still charged a ridiculous price. Won't be ordering anymore.
-
November 2023 by Stephanie Hitsman
Used to be great but the last few times we have ordered have not been. Forgot my Parmesan cheese and extra garlic butter that I paid for. Also asked for pie cut and got pretty uneven squares. Tastes ok but consistently missing items from my order- sometimes a 2 lt of pop, sometimes a salad, this time the extra garlic butter. Never get refunds back for missing items— so make sure you are double and triple checking everything before the delivery driver leaves.
-
November 2023 by Hillary West
I really like cristys, I enjoy the food & it's good. But $11.50-$12.00 for a sub is insane to me. You get like 2 pieces of meat on it. This is the Italian & I feel like I am just eating bread. The prices are what will unfortunately make us go somewhere else.
-
November 2023 by Tracy Sharp
If they would just cook the pizza's for like 4 minutes longer it would be awesome. We still get it and it is good but I say the same thing every time. Please cook them just a smidge longer.
-
October 2023 by Christopher Towe
Great Pizza. Yum.
-
July 2023 by Isaac Butcher
Very expensive for just pizza! Not worth the price.
-
May 2023 by Chelsea R.
Cristy's was always great about delivering food to us when I worked at Kenworth. We ordered 2-3 times a month and it was always hot and prompt, and the order was always correct. Their pizza is delicious!
-
February 2023 by carl carl
Told 20 minutes for order, got notification pizza was ready for pickup , got there and had to wait an additional 20 minutes after it took them 5 minutes to even figure what my order was. 3 people playing on their phones while I waited my additional 20 minutes. Food was definitely not worth a 40 minute wait. This will be my last trip here
-
December 2022 by Lisa Gillette
Always great pizza!
