-
January 2026 by Joy Lipscomb
Cute little grocery. Jams, jellies, candies, baked goods , nuts, flours . A little bit of everything you’d think you would find in a country store.
-
January 2026 by angela white
So many choices of items....if bulk items are what you are looking for go check them out!
-
December 2025 by Dave Capkovitz
This is a gem and you need to stop in. A great sandwich, fantastic baked goods and sweets as well as baking supplies. Come support these salt of the earth people.
-
December 2025 by Cheryl Karran
Wonderful people, huge selection of spices, awesome baked goods and a deli
-
December 2025 by Bryan B
Bought French dressing sugar cookies, shells and elbow, and homemade bread
-
December 2025 by Leslie McPeeks
A great little store where you can find many items sold in bulk. They carry many different jams and jellies, natural peanut butter, syrups, candy, baking products, and pantry items. There is also a bakery and a deli where you can order sandwiches, with a little seating area off to the side. This is definitely a place to visit if you're looking for something different!
-
November 2025 by Rachel Keith
Great new store. Super cute style and the staff is helpful and friendly. Definitely worth checking out especially during the holiday season lots of yummy gift ideas for gift baskets like hard to find Amish made jellies jams and baking stuff. Prices are very reasonable
-
November 2025 by Chris Jurick
Awesome Italian sub
-
October 2025 by Stephanie Glotzbecker
I was in need of some spices, and I new this was the place to go!! I also needed ground flax seed, chia seeds, almond flour and tapioca flour. I got everything on my list, and then some!!
-
October 2025 by SMH
Nice, clean store, good parking, close to the highway - selling Mennonite/Amish products but not quite the same a country Mennonite/Amish pantry - little more grocery like - rock music playing BUT good sandwiches, baked goods, bread and bulk products so I’d come again.
-
October 2025 by Ryan Orsborne Sr
Best place for all your ingredients, lunch meats and sandwiches along with many other items.
-
September 2025 by Linda Bernay
The quality of bakery items and deli items is excellent. The store is clean and provides a wide variety of items. Excellent place!
-
September 2025 by Anna Mitchell
I took my dad to the Old Mill Pantry. We loved everything there right down to even the building it self. Good selection. Everything we've tried there has been very delicious.
-
September 2025 by Christy Spehar
Very unique place!! Even a deli/food items. Prices are reasonable.
Only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 was because our cashier was not friendly. At all.
-
September 2025 by Mary McGinnis
Many bulk items at reasonable prices. Deli sandwich was delicious.
