-
March 2024 by Kerri
The pizza is delicious as always! Papa John's is our favorite pizza place and they have never failed to make good pizza. They have angry option you could want and out of all the pizza places in bethel, this place is the absolute best!
-
February 2024 by Desperation M
Good food and they
-
February 2024 by E. “Doc” Siler
Paige and Patience are awesome. Their mom is cool.
-
February 2024 by JP Althaus
Don’t recommend unless you want food poisoning. Ordered a pizza Thursday night. Woke up around 2am Friday morning with me running to the bathroom. I have been puking and diarrhea ever since. I’m just now able to keep some water down, but for the last 24hrs even a small sip of water I was puking it right back up. I could point out a couple of other things but they pale in comparison to my experience over the last 48hrs.
-
January 2024 by Ass Hole
Can't go wron with Pizza and a movie! They already know just how I like my orders prepared too...Great food super nice stuff never any problems with
-
January 2024 by TJ
Called it in and by the time I got there ( maybe 12 minutes) it was hot and ready can't ask for more than
-
November 2023 by Russ Hughes
Always great for pizza and the like ! Order ahead and take it with ya ?
-
November 2023 by Frank Hering
A hot meal that isn't fried with a vegetarian menu and gluten-free options for those of you that have to worry.Wheelchair accessibility: The handicapped spot isn't clearly labeled or marked. It's at the edge of the building, unless you want to use the ramp at Gold Star 10 spaces down as an alternate.
-
November 2023 by Tracy A
This Papa John's is a great restaurant in our small town. Isaiah was great and he is always friendly and makes a great pizza!
-
July 2023 by Angi Thomann
Wanted to give a shout out to the delivery driver Darrel he went above and beyond today I'm not even gonna tell you did cause I don't want you expecting it from him again laugh out loud thanks Darrel.
-
June 2023 by Zac Grand
Never gives me the right dip cups.
-
May 2023 by Brandon Millihan
Quick and delicious!
-
May 2023 by Matt Nickley
Hands down the best papajohns location I've ever been to.Had bad experiences at multiple Columbus and Dayton locations in the past but decided to give Bethel a try.After multiple orders all being perfectly prepared I had to hop on here and give you guys a good review.Keep up the quality and I'll keep coming back ?Pics show 3 different spot on orders.
-
April 2023 by Ronnie Wilson
Lost my online order and had to reorder and wait. Sitting right in front of store still had to go back in. Then had to wait at counter for help, with five people working in restaurant.
-
January 2023 by Tori Smedley
This order was a nightmare. I ordered one large pizza at 5:20pm. Around 6:30pm, I received a call but could not hear the person on the other end. Afraid that it was my driver and having had issues in the past with the app and our address, I tried to call the number back and it went straight to voicemail. I tried multiple times before deciding to call the Bethel, Ohio location that I had ordered from. I explained to the associate on the phone that the app had my address incorrect and that I had put the correct address in the driver notes as well as telling her it was the first house on the left. She placed me on hold for several minutes to status my order and then came back to tell me that it would be delivered shortly. I waited 25 more minutes. My home is 11 minutes from the store. I called again to be told that it would be here in one to two minutes. I said ok and disconnected. About 5 minutes later, the app updated to delivered so I called the store a 3rd time. This time I was told that the delivery driver came back to the store and that it would be another 30 minutes. At this point, it had been 2 hours since my order. I asked to speak with a manager.The manager, Trevor came on the phone and I explained the situation, how long I had been waiting, that I had tried to call a couple of times to clarify the address and that at this point, I did not think I should have to pay for my pizza. He said that he could send it back out but it was my fault due to the address, so they were not going to refund the pizza. I told him that it's fine, I'll pay for my pizza but that was not good customer service given the length of time as well as being told multiple times that it was almost here even after giving the correct address. He told me that I was just trying to get free pizza. He did eventually state that he would issue a credit for a free pizza because he was too busy and that his delivery driver would send back out. I order from this location all the time and do not care to pay for a $20 pizza. That was not the point.Finally got my pizza after 3 hours. I tipped my driver the cost of the pizza plus normal tip because it isn't her fault - and because it wasn't about trying to get a free pizza.
