-
March 2024 by Matt Thompson
Frankie is the absolute best server you can ask for..Parking: Trucks welcome In back of lot
-
March 2024 by Bill McArthur
Great little place that is amazing inside, but also great for food pickup.
-
March 2024 by Jessica Chesnut
A delightful dining experience or get it to go. The pizza cottage lives up to its name with some of the best pizza I've ever had.
-
February 2024 by Dustin Penwell
Was a pick up order best pizza and sub from a pizza place ever was less than 20 min from order to
-
February 2024 by Julia Tewksbary
Disappoited Mexican
-
February 2024 by Don Bennett
Good service with nice people Good
-
February 2024 by Chad Wood
Probably my favorite pizza in
-
February 2024 by Joseph Martin
Staff was very helpful even when google pay wasnt properly working. Most definatly will recommend to friends an will
-
February 2024 by Brandon Lee
So I just moved back to Columbus from Miami, FL after 3.5 years. My husband has been craving the BLT pizza since we moved. We have been back in Ohio 6 days and have had pizza cottage 4 of those nights for dinner from the Powell location. We just stopped in to the Buckeye Lake location to have lunch with my mother in law, everything was great just like at the other location. They were busy, as expected on a Sunday, but still very attentive and the food is TOP TIER.
-
February 2024 by Mike Fasone
People where plesent and easy to talk to. Food was good. We like going out there attest once a week. I enjoyed the cottage, Thanks.
-
January 2024 by Jim Hadinger
Quite possibly the best pizza I have ever eaten. The Whole Hog pizza was fantastic. I will definitely go back when I get the chance.
-
January 2024 by Tonya D'Amato
First of all I'll start by saying I've always loved pizza cottage. I worked at one for many years. My experience this time at buckeye lake location was terrible. Subs came out right away pizzas came 45 min later and our server we only saw 3 times in the 2 hours of visiting. The pizza was cold once it came as well. I think winter fest was the same day so maybe by 5pm they were just eschatology but something needs to change. Get it together or business will dwindle.
-
January 2024 by Kevin
Nice cozy restaurant great service and a large variety of
-
January 2024 by Chip Sluder
Haven't gone to pizza cottage for awhile. ...ordered a Italian sub 4 dinner today needles to say I'll NEVER GO THERE AGAIN!!!!!! Spent 10$ for 2peices of bread a pinch lettuce 3 tomatoes the size of a nickel 3 hot peppers and I don't think there was slim to no cheese needless to say where's the meat other than that tasted good but if that's standard ur subs r sinking......
-
January 2024 by Julia M George
Salad was the best! Iceberg lettuce pizza was good
