-
February 2024 by Eric Ellsworth
Its the Best morrow
-
February 2024 by Chelsie Squires
ITALIAN SUB was awesome tonight !
-
February 2024 by Buster Clark
Great pizza and subs and
-
December 2023 by Crystal Weber
I ordered a cheese steak sub with no onions and no peppers add mushrooms. I also asked that they wrap it so that when I opened it up the cheese did all stick to the foil. When I got home and opened up my sub the cheese stuck to the foil and it was loaded with onions and peppers. I tried picking them off but they were chopped into small pieces so that didn't work. I was not impressed to say the least.
-
December 2023 by Chelsey Garrabrant
Hot and fresh pizza and one of the best salads in Morrow County!
-
November 2023 by Susie Bennett
Absolutely recommend!!! Owner is the best! Staff is great. Food is delicious ?
-
November 2023 by Debra Steen
As a first time customer I will not return.The subs I bought was burnt and stuck to the aluminum foil. After I got the sandwich unstuck there was no bun on the bottom, made it impossible to eat without a fork.Not a good experience with this place or their Italian subs.
-
October 2023 by Joseph Wheat
We used to go to Pirate's Cove quite often. They HAD the best subs in the area and surrounding. We went there tonight and are very disappointed. The subs used to overflow with fillings (especially cheese). It seems now they put half of what they used to on their subs. My daughter got an italian sub and they didn't put salami on it, so she basically got a ham sub. It's just not worth the 30 minute drive any more. And I will no longer be bragging about the subs to anyone I know. Bring back the previous owners!
-
October 2023 by Adrian Torrey
Pleasantly surprised by Pirates Cove Pizza. Had it for the first time tonight and ordered online, super easy process. Customer service was great. Pizza was delicious, left a little to be desired in the crust but overall a great pizza: no holding back on the toppings (great topping choices), sauce and cheese are 10/10, and worth the money. Will be eating here again!
-
June 2023 by Nick Woodbury
Delicious pizza, and amazing staff! My favorite thing about this place is you can order custom pizzas! (still waiting for them to have the ingredients for my Krusty Krab Pizza), but If they have the ingredients they can make just about anything you can think of. They just started carrying wings which have a good amount of meat on them along with good sauce choices. Keep up the great work!
-
May 2023 by Cole DesJardins
This has been my favorite pizza place by far for many years. Excellent food and always wonderful staff. Pizza is unique and tastes amazing. Can’t go wrong with pirates cove. Flakey crust, thick toppings, great flavor
-
April 2023 by Big Iron Construction LLC
We got pizza and subs here last night food was on time place was clean. Best food we had in a long time . We will be back!!!
-
April 2023 by CRAIG MATTHEWS
We got pizza and subs here last night food was on time place was clean. Best food we had in a long time . We will be back!!!
-
February 2023 by Cuyler Rigney
Some of the best tasting pizza dough I've had.
-
January 2023 by crystal wallace
Love this local pizza shop. Excited about the new menu with gluten free options. Great staff great food.
