-
March 2024 by Blake Lazor
I placed order on line paid for it and then got a message they don't deliver to me. I called them to pick up and service was absolutely horrible. Aaidni jad ro place order shin and then just hung up and did not even take my order. I would not recommend very horrible aervice.
-
March 2024 by James Matson
I will never go back to Buckeye..I have been there couple of times in last few weeks..this one did me in..they are not consistant..I ordered a thin crust 25 $ pizza..very disappointed it..wasn't even hot when I got it..and needless to say..it was cold and doughy..it just disappointed me..it was a SAS
-
February 2024 by James Digit
Two times I went here in the mid-late afternoon. Neither time were they open for business. HARD PASS.
-
January 2024 by Charles E Carpenter
Good pizza and
-
January 2024 by Nellie
Outrageous
-
January 2024 by Complex Talent
Got me when I needed itKid-friendliness: They are caring
-
December 2023 by Shane Walton
Ordered pizza on Christmas via door dash. It’s hard to describe the pizza - obvious frozen crust, a modicum of unspectacular sauce, decent cheese, and a smattering of pepperoni. My wife had one piece and stopped. I continued on for 3 pieces total. Not complete garbage but not great. If you’re hungry and there’s nothing else open, it might be for you.
-
December 2023 by Tre Olson
Had delivery that came on time/slightly early. Tried the Buckeye sauce on some chicken tenders. Interesting taste. They said it's a mix of 3 different sauces, hot, ranch, and I can't remember the other. The tenders had a good crunch despite being covered in sauce. Give it a shot. Pizza was good, not fantastic, but great for the price. They did not send a plastic ware or enough napkins for the tenders.
-
November 2023 by Michael S
Pizza is good, but the pick-up experience is very sub-par. The staff just treats you like cattle, that is, if they even pay attention that you walked into the store.
-
November 2023 by William W. Wess
The wings are on some of the best I've ever tasted!!!! I go they're just to try the wings!!!
-
October 2023 by Miranda Romig
Definitely not worth the price point. Reminded me of Chuck E. Cheese pizza.
-
October 2023 by Charles Truss
My delivery driver pulled and popped the car trunk and delivered my pizza ? with no change in his pocket,
-
September 2023 by Katsparrow
We placed a very big order a week ago and ended up throwing most all of it out. There wasn't any flavor in any of the pizzas, subs, or sides that we got. I don't think we're going to order here again.
-
August 2023 by Katie B
DO. NOT. ORDER. HERE. EVER. Read the bad reviews, but decided to give them benefit of the doubt. Ordered off grubhub for pick up. Arrived at the store at 1:15pm after my order pickup time was pushed back 30 minutes. Place was closed. Doors were locked even though open sign was on. Tried to call but they didn’t answer. Dont post hours online or on your doors if you can’t stick to them. Absolutely awful customer service and I bet the pizza tastes god awful too. You should be ashamed of yourselves.
-
July 2023 by Stan T.
Visiting in Columbus. Was late night hungry. Got a large pepperoni with extra sauce. 1) the pizza was over 30 minutes late. 2) the pizza was cold.3) the pizza was burnt.4) if this was extra sauce, I feel very sorry for people that don't. That was the driest pizzas I have ever tried.That's prettier much it.