Play It Again Sports Reynoldsburg is a well-regarded sporting goods store in Columbus, OH, specializing in equipment for fitness, football, baseball, lacrosse, and soccer. Customers appreciate the store's wide selection of new and used sports gear, with many highlighting the helpful and knowledgeable staff. The team is praised for their willingness to assist in finding the right equipment at affordable prices and for providing excellent customer service. Visitors often find exactly what they need quickly, whether it's a glove for softball, football gear, or other sports equipment. The store is also known for offering top dollar for used equipment in good condition. Many customers recommend Play It Again Sports to fellow coaches, athletes, and family members, citing positive first-time experiences and the variety of brands and price points available. Overall, the store is seen as a reliable place to get high-quality sports gear, with friendly staff dedicated to ensuring customers leave satisfied and equipped to perform their best.
Large selection of used gear even had new roller skates
February 2026
I’ve been a long time customer from 1993 to present. I usually check here before going to the big names sport stores.
November 2025
This is a great location and the staff is knowledgeable and super friendly! Cashier was kind and informative about our selection. It’s kids friendly and I felt cared for here we will return for more!
