Pearl Valley Cheese Inc. is a nice little hidden place in Amish Country and a must-see. It is recommended for its amazing cheese, described as the best, the creamiest, and with great texture and full flavors. Favorites include the horseradish, chipotle, and salsa cheeses. There is not a big selection of cheeses, but the prices are great, amazing, and reasonable, especially in the bargain bin. The staff is friendly, helpful, patient, and knowledgeable. You can sample any cheese and watch the cheese making process through a large window. They also offer pre-cubed cheese or will cube cheese to order. The business has some different flavored mustards, summer sausage, beef sticks, crackers, local wine, snacks, and old fashioned candy. They offer a wide range of gift boxes and ship their cheese. It is a 10/10 recommended place to visit.
I went for my company fundraiser. Everyone was so friendly and helpful. They didn't make me feel bad when I had an unfortunate card issue 😔 We just worked through it and they gave me a 'snack bag' to travel home with 😁 Definitely will return both professionally and on personal time.
March 2026
Amazing cheese that's made on the premises. Staff is amazingly helpful.
March 2026
This is a great processing/outlet for cheese and butter. Have produced award winning cheese. Also has a small delicatessen area with assortment of cheese and meats.
