Sheetz of Hartville is a convenience store that offers a wide range of services and products to its customers. Known for its award-winning Made-To-Order food and handcrafted Sheetz Bros. Coffeez drinks, Sheetz provides a kicked-up convenience experience. The store is open 24/7 and offers a variety of packaged snacks, drinks, tobacco, and CBD products to cater to diverse customer needs. Customers generally have a positive experience at Sheetz, praising the quality of the food and the variety of options available, which are often better than typical gas station offerings. The store is described as a fun place to get food, with some customers even comparing it to fast food restaurants in terms of quality. However, there have been a few instances where the food was not up to par, and some customers found certain items to be a bit pricey. The service at Sheetz is generally praised, with friendly and attentive staff. However, there have been a few instances where customers had to wait for an extended period to pay for their purchases or receive their orders. Despite these occasional hiccups, Sheetz is seen as a reliable and convenient option, always open and ready to satisfy customers' needs, even at odd hours of the day.
Apparently no 1 pays attention to what is going on in there. I watched a man and woman fill her purse up with stuff and then take a couple milk shakes on their way out.
May 2026
Best Milkshakes ever. Ask for extra chocolate if getting a chocolate shake. Excellent service. Carson is great at Hartville Sheetz.
April 2026
Just stopped in for a quick fountain drink. The gentleman at the front counter was very friendly and the bathroom was clean. I recommend stopping at this Sheetz.
